Words and Worlds Turned Around: Indigenous Christianities in Colonial Latin America
edited by David Tavárez foreword by William Taylor
University Press of Colorado, 2017 Paper: 978-1-60732-683-0 | eISBN: 978-1-60732-684-7 Library of Congress Classification F1219.3.R38W67 2017 Dewey Decimal Classification 980.01
ABOUT THIS BOOK | AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY | REVIEWS | TOC | REQUEST ACCESSIBLE FILE
ABOUT THIS BOOK
A sophisticated, state-of-the-art study of the remaking of Christianity by indigenous societies, Words and Worlds Turned Around reveals the manifold transformations of Christian discourses in the colonial Americas. The book surveys how Christian messages were rendered in indigenous languages; explores what was added, transformed, or glossed over; and ends with an epilogue about contemporary Nahuatl Christianities.
In eleven case studies drawn from eight Amerindian languages—Nahuatl, Northern and Valley Zapotec, Quechua, Yucatec Maya, K'iche' Maya, Q'eqchi' Maya, and Tupi—the authors address Christian texts and traditions that were repeatedly changed through translation—a process of “turning around” as conveyed in Classical Nahuatl. Through an examination of how Christian terms and practices were made, remade, and negotiated by both missionaries and native authors and audiences, the volume shows the conversion of indigenous peoples as an ongoing process influenced by what native societies sought, understood, or accepted.
The volume features a rapprochement of methodologies and assumptions employed in history, anthropology, and religion and combines the acuity of of methodologies drawn from philology and historical linguistics with the contextualizing force of the ethnohistory and social history of Spanish and Portuguese America.
Contributors: Claudia Brosseder, Louise M. Burkhart, Mark Christensen, John F. Chuchiak IV, Abelardo de la Cruz, Gregory Haimovich, Kittiya Lee, Ben Leeming, Julia Madajczak, Justyna Olko, Frauke Sachse, Garry Sparks
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY
David Tavárez, a professor of anthropology at Vassar College, is the author of Rethinking Zapotec Time Cosmology, Ritual, and Resistance in Colonial Mexico and The Invisible War: Indigenous Devotions, Discipline, and Dissent in Colonial Mexico, and a coauthor of two volumes, Painted Words, andChimalpahin’s Conquest. He has also published more than sixty peer-reviewed articles and chapters on Latin American history, linguistic anthropology, and Mesoamerican studies. A recipient of a Guggenheim Fellowship, his research has also been supported by grants from the National Endowment for the Humanities, the National Science Foundation, and the John Carter Brown Library.
REVIEWS
“As pathbreaking and revisionist as what Robert Ricard advocated some eighty years ago. . . . A most welcome addition to the ethnohistory of colonial Latin America. Most valuable is its originality and the exacting level of scholarship necessary to generate such important studies.” —Susan Schroeder, Tulane University
“An intriguing assembly of cross-disciplinary investigations, exploring from different angles the ways in which indigenous Christianities emerged and proliferated in Spanish America. This volume raises big questions for the study of some purportedly old processes and breathes new life into the art of historical interpretation.” —Kenneth Mills, University of Michigan
"These [essays] help show what happened on some of the most daunting frontiers of cultural exchange, where distinctive forms of Catholicism emerged. Creative misunderstandings, tense collaborations, fruitful contention: every type of encounter is represented here, with vivid evocations." —Felipe Fernández-Armesto, University of Notre Dame
"This book is part of an important moment in the historiography of colonial Latin America. . . . [and represents] the cutting-edge research that is redefining the study of indigenous religions of the Americas and their relationship toChristianity." —Reading Religion
"Together, this volume’s chapters highlight the variety of Catholicisms presented to the Indigenous populations of Latin America and how Native peoples localized Christianity and remade it according to their own cultural logic. . . . Summing Up: Recommended" —Choice
“This volume of essays is recommended for all scholars and students of religion and indigenous peoples of the Americas.” —International Journal of Latin American Religion
"Each chapter illustrates innovative approaches that challenge the narrow perception of a one-way "spiritual conquest," engaging the reader with the complexities of translating (converting) Christianity into a new (geo-graphical) context." —Latin American Antiquity
"The work’s geographic breadth, the rich array of sources introduced by contributors, and several strong and novel analyses make this an important contribution to a dynamic field of study." —Ethnohistory
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Contents
List of Illustrations
Foreword / William B. Taylor
Acknowledgments
Maps
Introduction / Louise M. Burkhart
Part I: First Contacts, First Inventions
1. Performing the Zaachila Word: The Dominican Invention of Zapotec Christianity / David Tavárez
2. Toward a Deconstruction of the Notion of Nahua “Confession” / Julia Madajczak
3. Precontact Indigenous Concepts in Christian Translations: The Terminology of Sin and Confession in Early Colonial Quechua Texts / Gregory Haimovich
4. A Sixteenth-Century Priest’s Field Notes among the Highland Maya: Proto-Theologia as Vade Mecum / Garry Sparks and Frauke Sachse
Part II: Indigenous Agency and Reception Strategies
5. International Collaborations in Translation: The European Promise of Militant Christianity for the Tupinambá of Portuguese America, 1550s–1612 / M. Kittiya Lee
6. The Nahua Story of Judas: Indigenous Agency and Loci of Meaning / Justyna Olko
7. A Nahua Christian Talks Back: Fabián de Aquino’s Antichrist Dramas as Autoethnography / Ben Leeming
Part III: Transformations, Appropriations, and Dialogues
8. Sin, Shame, and Sexuality: Franciscan Obsessions and Maya Humor in the Calepino de Motul Dictionary, 1573–1615 / John F. Chuchiak IV
9. To Make Christianity Fit: The Process of Christianization from an Andean Perspective / Claudia Brosseder
10. Predictions and Portents of Doomsday in European, Nahuatl, and Maya Texts / Mark Z. Christensen
Part IV: Contemporary Nahua Christianities
11. The Value of El Costumbre and Christianity in the Discourse of Nahua Catechists from the Huasteca Region in Veracruz, Mexico, 1970s–2010s / Abelardo de la Cruz
Conclusions / David Tavárez
Glossary
About the Authors
Index
REQUEST ACCESSIBLE FILE
If you are a student who cannot use this book in printed form, BiblioVault may be able to supply you
with an electronic file for alternative access.
Please have the accessibility coordinator at your school fill out this form.
Words and Worlds Turned Around: Indigenous Christianities in Colonial Latin America
edited by David Tavárez foreword by William Taylor
University Press of Colorado, 2017 Paper: 978-1-60732-683-0 eISBN: 978-1-60732-684-7
A sophisticated, state-of-the-art study of the remaking of Christianity by indigenous societies, Words and Worlds Turned Around reveals the manifold transformations of Christian discourses in the colonial Americas. The book surveys how Christian messages were rendered in indigenous languages; explores what was added, transformed, or glossed over; and ends with an epilogue about contemporary Nahuatl Christianities.
In eleven case studies drawn from eight Amerindian languages—Nahuatl, Northern and Valley Zapotec, Quechua, Yucatec Maya, K'iche' Maya, Q'eqchi' Maya, and Tupi—the authors address Christian texts and traditions that were repeatedly changed through translation—a process of “turning around” as conveyed in Classical Nahuatl. Through an examination of how Christian terms and practices were made, remade, and negotiated by both missionaries and native authors and audiences, the volume shows the conversion of indigenous peoples as an ongoing process influenced by what native societies sought, understood, or accepted.
The volume features a rapprochement of methodologies and assumptions employed in history, anthropology, and religion and combines the acuity of of methodologies drawn from philology and historical linguistics with the contextualizing force of the ethnohistory and social history of Spanish and Portuguese America.
Contributors: Claudia Brosseder, Louise M. Burkhart, Mark Christensen, John F. Chuchiak IV, Abelardo de la Cruz, Gregory Haimovich, Kittiya Lee, Ben Leeming, Julia Madajczak, Justyna Olko, Frauke Sachse, Garry Sparks
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY
David Tavárez, a professor of anthropology at Vassar College, is the author of Rethinking Zapotec Time Cosmology, Ritual, and Resistance in Colonial Mexico and The Invisible War: Indigenous Devotions, Discipline, and Dissent in Colonial Mexico, and a coauthor of two volumes, Painted Words, andChimalpahin’s Conquest. He has also published more than sixty peer-reviewed articles and chapters on Latin American history, linguistic anthropology, and Mesoamerican studies. A recipient of a Guggenheim Fellowship, his research has also been supported by grants from the National Endowment for the Humanities, the National Science Foundation, and the John Carter Brown Library.
REVIEWS
“As pathbreaking and revisionist as what Robert Ricard advocated some eighty years ago. . . . A most welcome addition to the ethnohistory of colonial Latin America. Most valuable is its originality and the exacting level of scholarship necessary to generate such important studies.” —Susan Schroeder, Tulane University
“An intriguing assembly of cross-disciplinary investigations, exploring from different angles the ways in which indigenous Christianities emerged and proliferated in Spanish America. This volume raises big questions for the study of some purportedly old processes and breathes new life into the art of historical interpretation.” —Kenneth Mills, University of Michigan
"These [essays] help show what happened on some of the most daunting frontiers of cultural exchange, where distinctive forms of Catholicism emerged. Creative misunderstandings, tense collaborations, fruitful contention: every type of encounter is represented here, with vivid evocations." —Felipe Fernández-Armesto, University of Notre Dame
"This book is part of an important moment in the historiography of colonial Latin America. . . . [and represents] the cutting-edge research that is redefining the study of indigenous religions of the Americas and their relationship toChristianity." —Reading Religion
"Together, this volume’s chapters highlight the variety of Catholicisms presented to the Indigenous populations of Latin America and how Native peoples localized Christianity and remade it according to their own cultural logic. . . . Summing Up: Recommended" —Choice
“This volume of essays is recommended for all scholars and students of religion and indigenous peoples of the Americas.” —International Journal of Latin American Religion
"Each chapter illustrates innovative approaches that challenge the narrow perception of a one-way "spiritual conquest," engaging the reader with the complexities of translating (converting) Christianity into a new (geo-graphical) context." —Latin American Antiquity
"The work’s geographic breadth, the rich array of sources introduced by contributors, and several strong and novel analyses make this an important contribution to a dynamic field of study." —Ethnohistory
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Contents
List of Illustrations
Foreword / William B. Taylor
Acknowledgments
Maps
Introduction / Louise M. Burkhart
Part I: First Contacts, First Inventions
1. Performing the Zaachila Word: The Dominican Invention of Zapotec Christianity / David Tavárez
2. Toward a Deconstruction of the Notion of Nahua “Confession” / Julia Madajczak
3. Precontact Indigenous Concepts in Christian Translations: The Terminology of Sin and Confession in Early Colonial Quechua Texts / Gregory Haimovich
4. A Sixteenth-Century Priest’s Field Notes among the Highland Maya: Proto-Theologia as Vade Mecum / Garry Sparks and Frauke Sachse
Part II: Indigenous Agency and Reception Strategies
5. International Collaborations in Translation: The European Promise of Militant Christianity for the Tupinambá of Portuguese America, 1550s–1612 / M. Kittiya Lee
6. The Nahua Story of Judas: Indigenous Agency and Loci of Meaning / Justyna Olko
7. A Nahua Christian Talks Back: Fabián de Aquino’s Antichrist Dramas as Autoethnography / Ben Leeming
Part III: Transformations, Appropriations, and Dialogues
8. Sin, Shame, and Sexuality: Franciscan Obsessions and Maya Humor in the Calepino de Motul Dictionary, 1573–1615 / John F. Chuchiak IV
9. To Make Christianity Fit: The Process of Christianization from an Andean Perspective / Claudia Brosseder
10. Predictions and Portents of Doomsday in European, Nahuatl, and Maya Texts / Mark Z. Christensen
Part IV: Contemporary Nahua Christianities
11. The Value of El Costumbre and Christianity in the Discourse of Nahua Catechists from the Huasteca Region in Veracruz, Mexico, 1970s–2010s / Abelardo de la Cruz
Conclusions / David Tavárez
Glossary
About the Authors
Index
REQUEST ACCESSIBLE FILE
If you are a student who cannot use this book in printed form, BiblioVault may be able to supply you
with an electronic file for alternative access.
Please have the accessibility coordinator at your school fill out this form.
It can take 2-3 weeks for requests to be filled.
ABOUT THIS BOOK | AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY | REVIEWS | TOC | REQUEST ACCESSIBLE FILE