Concepts and Their Role in Knowledge: Reflections on Objectivist Epistemology
edited by Allan Gotthelf and James G. Lennox
University of Pittsburgh Press, 2022 eISBN: 978-0-8229-7856-5 | Cloth: 978-0-8229-4424-9 | Paper: 978-0-8229-6701-9 Library of Congress Classification B945.R234C66 2013 Dewey Decimal Classification 121.4
ABOUT THIS BOOK | AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY | REVIEWS | TOC | REQUEST ACCESSIBLE FILE
ABOUT THIS BOOK
The philosopher and novelist Ayn Rand (1905–1982) is a cultural phenomenon. Her books have sold more than twenty-eight million copies, and countless individuals speak of her writings as having significantly influenced their lives. Despite her popularity, Rand’s philosophy of Objectivism has received little serious attention from academic philosophers.
Concepts and Their Role in Knowledge offers scholarly analysis of key elements of Ayn Rand’s radically new approach to epistemology. The four essays, by contributors intimately familiar with this area of her work, discuss Rand’s theory of concepts—including its new account of abstraction and essence—and its central role in her epistemology; how that view leads to a distinctive conception of the justification of knowledge; her realist account of perceptual awareness and its role in the acquisition of knowledge; and finally, the implications of that theory for understanding the growth of scientific knowledge. The volume concludes with critical commentary on the essays by distinguished philosophers with differing philosophical viewpoints and the author’s responses to those commentaries.
This is the second book published in Ayn Rand Society Philosophical Studies, which was developed in conjunction with the Ayn Rand Society to offer a fuller scholarly understanding of this highly original and influential thinker. The Ayn Rand Society, an affiliated group of the American Philosophical Association, Eastern Division, seeks to foster scholarly study by philosophers of the philosophical thought and writings of Ayn Rand.
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY
Allan Gotthelf (1942–2013) was visiting professor of the history and philosophy of science at the University of Pittsburgh from 2003 to 2012 and Anthem Foundation Distinguished Fellow for Research and Teaching in Philosophy at Rutgers University from 2012 to 2013. He is the author of On Ayn Rand and Teleology, First Principles, and Scientific Method in Aristotle’s Biology and coeditor of Philosophical Issues in Aristotle’s Biology and Ayn Rand: A Companion to Her Works and Thought. He was a founding member of the Ayn Rand Society and coeditor of the Ayn Rand Society Philosophical Studies book series.
James G. Lennox is professor emeritus of history and philosophy of science at the University of Pittsburgh. He is the author of Aristotle on Inquiry, Aristotle: On the Parts of Animals I–IV, and Aristotle’s Philosophy of Biology: Studies in the Origins of Life Science. Lennox is coeditor of Philosophical Issues in Aristotle’s Biology; Being, Nature, and Life in Aristotle: Essays in Honor of Allan Gotthelf; and Concepts, Theories, and Rationality in the Biological Sciences. He was a founding member of the Ayn Rand Society and is coeditor of the Ayn Rand Society Philosophical Studies series.
REVIEWS
“A landmark set of essays, with comments and responses, exploring the implications of Rand's theories on perception, concept-formation, definition, justification, and conceptual change in science. The publication of this remarkable and engaging volume brings to the attention of professionals a theory of knowledge whose depth, breadth, and nuance may surprise them.”
—Harry Binswanger, Editor, second edition of Ayn Rand’s Introduction to Objectivist Epistemology
“By locating Rand’s theory of concepts in both traditional and contemporary debates, this collection offers a textured portrait of her distinctive view while also advancing the debates themselves. The essays are uniformly engaging and incisive, making substantial contributions on such topics as definitions, theory change, and epistemic justification. The crosscurrents in the comments and responses make the issues come alive, and broader applications (such as for value theory) are apparent. Overall, a terrific contribution.”
—Tara A. Smith, University of Texas-Austin
“This second volume of Ayn Rand Society Philosophical Studies provides extensive analysis of Ayn Rand’s epistemology, the most important—but perhaps the least well-known—part of her philosophy of Objectivism. Contributed by scholars both sympathetic to and critical of Rand’s approach, these revealing essays address a wide range of topics, including Rand’s unique accounts of concept-formation and objectivity.”
—Darryl Wright, Harvey Mudd College
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Contents
Preface
Part One: Essays
Ayn Rand’s Theory of Concepts: Rethinking Abstraction and Essence / Allan Gotthelf
Conceptualization and Justification / Gregory Salmieri
Perceptual Awareness as Presentational / Onkar Ghate
Concepts, Context, and the Advance of Science / James G. Lennox
Part Two: Discussion
Concepts and Kinds
Rand on Concepts, Definitions, and the Advance of Science: Comments on Gotthelf and Lennox / Paul E. Griffiths
Natural Kinds and Rand’s Theory of Concepts: Reflections on Griffiths / Onkar Ghate
Definitions
Rand on Definitions—One Size Fits All?: Comments on Gotthelf / Jim Bogen
Taking the Measure of a Definition: Response to Bogen / Allan Gotthelf
Concepts and Theory Change
On Concepts that Change with the Advance of Science: Comments on Lennox / Richard M. Burian
Conceptual Development versus Conceptual Change: Response to Burian / James G. Lennox
Perceptual Awareness
In Defense of the Theory of Appearing: Comments on Ghate and Salmieri / Pierre Le Morvan
Forms of Awareness and “Three-Factor” Theories / Gregory Salmieri
Direct Perception and Salmieri’s “Forms of Awareness” / Bill Brewer
Keeping Up Appearances: Reflections on the Debate over Perceptual Infallibilism / Benjamin Bayer
Uniform Abbreviations of Works by Ayn Rand
References
Contributors
Index
REQUEST ACCESSIBLE FILE
If you are a student who cannot use this book in printed form, BiblioVault may be able to supply you
with an electronic file for alternative access.
Please have the accessibility coordinator at your school fill out this form.
Concepts and Their Role in Knowledge: Reflections on Objectivist Epistemology
edited by Allan Gotthelf and James G. Lennox
University of Pittsburgh Press, 2022 eISBN: 978-0-8229-7856-5 Cloth: 978-0-8229-4424-9 Paper: 978-0-8229-6701-9
The philosopher and novelist Ayn Rand (1905–1982) is a cultural phenomenon. Her books have sold more than twenty-eight million copies, and countless individuals speak of her writings as having significantly influenced their lives. Despite her popularity, Rand’s philosophy of Objectivism has received little serious attention from academic philosophers.
Concepts and Their Role in Knowledge offers scholarly analysis of key elements of Ayn Rand’s radically new approach to epistemology. The four essays, by contributors intimately familiar with this area of her work, discuss Rand’s theory of concepts—including its new account of abstraction and essence—and its central role in her epistemology; how that view leads to a distinctive conception of the justification of knowledge; her realist account of perceptual awareness and its role in the acquisition of knowledge; and finally, the implications of that theory for understanding the growth of scientific knowledge. The volume concludes with critical commentary on the essays by distinguished philosophers with differing philosophical viewpoints and the author’s responses to those commentaries.
This is the second book published in Ayn Rand Society Philosophical Studies, which was developed in conjunction with the Ayn Rand Society to offer a fuller scholarly understanding of this highly original and influential thinker. The Ayn Rand Society, an affiliated group of the American Philosophical Association, Eastern Division, seeks to foster scholarly study by philosophers of the philosophical thought and writings of Ayn Rand.
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY
Allan Gotthelf (1942–2013) was visiting professor of the history and philosophy of science at the University of Pittsburgh from 2003 to 2012 and Anthem Foundation Distinguished Fellow for Research and Teaching in Philosophy at Rutgers University from 2012 to 2013. He is the author of On Ayn Rand and Teleology, First Principles, and Scientific Method in Aristotle’s Biology and coeditor of Philosophical Issues in Aristotle’s Biology and Ayn Rand: A Companion to Her Works and Thought. He was a founding member of the Ayn Rand Society and coeditor of the Ayn Rand Society Philosophical Studies book series.
James G. Lennox is professor emeritus of history and philosophy of science at the University of Pittsburgh. He is the author of Aristotle on Inquiry, Aristotle: On the Parts of Animals I–IV, and Aristotle’s Philosophy of Biology: Studies in the Origins of Life Science. Lennox is coeditor of Philosophical Issues in Aristotle’s Biology; Being, Nature, and Life in Aristotle: Essays in Honor of Allan Gotthelf; and Concepts, Theories, and Rationality in the Biological Sciences. He was a founding member of the Ayn Rand Society and is coeditor of the Ayn Rand Society Philosophical Studies series.
REVIEWS
“A landmark set of essays, with comments and responses, exploring the implications of Rand's theories on perception, concept-formation, definition, justification, and conceptual change in science. The publication of this remarkable and engaging volume brings to the attention of professionals a theory of knowledge whose depth, breadth, and nuance may surprise them.”
—Harry Binswanger, Editor, second edition of Ayn Rand’s Introduction to Objectivist Epistemology
“By locating Rand’s theory of concepts in both traditional and contemporary debates, this collection offers a textured portrait of her distinctive view while also advancing the debates themselves. The essays are uniformly engaging and incisive, making substantial contributions on such topics as definitions, theory change, and epistemic justification. The crosscurrents in the comments and responses make the issues come alive, and broader applications (such as for value theory) are apparent. Overall, a terrific contribution.”
—Tara A. Smith, University of Texas-Austin
“This second volume of Ayn Rand Society Philosophical Studies provides extensive analysis of Ayn Rand’s epistemology, the most important—but perhaps the least well-known—part of her philosophy of Objectivism. Contributed by scholars both sympathetic to and critical of Rand’s approach, these revealing essays address a wide range of topics, including Rand’s unique accounts of concept-formation and objectivity.”
—Darryl Wright, Harvey Mudd College
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Contents
Preface
Part One: Essays
Ayn Rand’s Theory of Concepts: Rethinking Abstraction and Essence / Allan Gotthelf
Conceptualization and Justification / Gregory Salmieri
Perceptual Awareness as Presentational / Onkar Ghate
Concepts, Context, and the Advance of Science / James G. Lennox
Part Two: Discussion
Concepts and Kinds
Rand on Concepts, Definitions, and the Advance of Science: Comments on Gotthelf and Lennox / Paul E. Griffiths
Natural Kinds and Rand’s Theory of Concepts: Reflections on Griffiths / Onkar Ghate
Definitions
Rand on Definitions—One Size Fits All?: Comments on Gotthelf / Jim Bogen
Taking the Measure of a Definition: Response to Bogen / Allan Gotthelf
Concepts and Theory Change
On Concepts that Change with the Advance of Science: Comments on Lennox / Richard M. Burian
Conceptual Development versus Conceptual Change: Response to Burian / James G. Lennox
Perceptual Awareness
In Defense of the Theory of Appearing: Comments on Ghate and Salmieri / Pierre Le Morvan
Forms of Awareness and “Three-Factor” Theories / Gregory Salmieri
Direct Perception and Salmieri’s “Forms of Awareness” / Bill Brewer
Keeping Up Appearances: Reflections on the Debate over Perceptual Infallibilism / Benjamin Bayer
Uniform Abbreviations of Works by Ayn Rand
References
Contributors
Index
REQUEST ACCESSIBLE FILE
If you are a student who cannot use this book in printed form, BiblioVault may be able to supply you
with an electronic file for alternative access.
Please have the accessibility coordinator at your school fill out this form.
It can take 2-3 weeks for requests to be filled.
ABOUT THIS BOOK | AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY | REVIEWS | TOC | REQUEST ACCESSIBLE FILE