Disciplinary Conquest: U.S. Scholars in South America, 1900–1945
by Ricardo D. Salvatore
Duke University Press, 2016 Paper: 978-0-8223-6095-7 | Cloth: 978-0-8223-6081-0 | eISBN: 978-0-8223-7450-3 Library of Congress Classification F1409.95.U6S25 2016
ABOUT THIS BOOK | AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY | REVIEWS | TOC | REQUEST ACCESSIBLE FILE
ABOUT THIS BOOK
In Disciplinary Conquest Ricardo D. Salvatore rewrites the origin story of Latin American studies by tracing the discipline's roots back to the first half of the twentieth century. Salvatore focuses on the work of five representative U.S. scholars of South America—historian Clarence Haring, geographer Isaiah Bowman, political scientist Leo Rowe, sociologist Edward Ross, and archaeologist Hiram Bingham—to show how Latin American studies was allied with U.S. business and foreign policy interests. Diplomats, policy makers, business investors, and the American public used the knowledge these and other scholars gathered to build an informal empire that fostered the growth of U.S. economic, technological, and cultural hegemony throughout the hemisphere. Tying the drive to know South America to the specialization and rise of Latin American studies, Salvatore shows how the disciplinary conquest of South America affirmed a new mode of American imperial engagement.
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY
Ricardo D. Salvatore is Plenary Professor at Universidad Torcuato Di Tella in Buenos Aires. He is the author of Wandering Paysanos: State Order and Subaltern Experience in Buenos Aires during the Rosas Era and coeditor of Crime and Punishment in Latin America: Law and Society Since Late Colonial Times, both also published by Duke University Press.
REVIEWS
"Not only a well-documented, nuanced, and challenging account, but also a rare and bold attempt to write the history of the hemisphere from South to North instead of from North to South, Disciplinary Conquest will hopefully be published also in Spanish and Portuguese and read by all practitioners in the field across the Americas and beyond."
-- Ori Preuss Journal of Latin American Studies
"This is a welcome and ambitious project that takes us into the empirical aspects of US-Latin American relations from the perspective of informal empires, with an original emphasis on the role of knowledge in the configuration of the powerful presence of the United States in the region. Extremely well documented and offering a narrative constructed from empirical data to make a point about hegemony, this book is a wonderful example of how situated knowledge can be explained in the structural context of inter-American relations."
-- H. Reuben Neptune American Historical Review
"Disciplinary Conquests offers an excellent and incisive account of U.S. scholars, their interest in (and relationship with) South America, and the links between the work of these scholars, empire, and foreign policy."
-- Evan C. Rothera Journal of Global South Studies
“[Salvatore] is, simply, a master raconteur. Disciplinary Conquest is essential reading for those with an interest in the evolution of inter-American relations.… It is a book that will assuredly warrant multiple rereadings.”
-- Philip Chrimes International Affairs
"Authoritatively written, [Disciplinary Conquest] is both theoretically valuable and empirically rich in detailed historical research, essential reading for understanding the crucial role of educational asymmetry and US universities in shaping thought leadership and hegemonic relations in the Western Hemisphere during the twentieth century. . . . A pleasure to read, each page with surprises that enrich the author’s project; readers will admire the meticulous detail of his research."
-- Edgar J. Dosman Latin American Research Review
"Disciplinary Conquest should be read by every scholar doing work in Latin America and teaching Latin American studies to undergraduate and graduate students. It is a valuable book that will promote intellectual debates about how we practice research and how our own aspirations lie within anything we write."
-- Yovanna Pineda The Latin Americanist
"Truly admirable in its scope and depth, Salvatore’s analysis provides a convincing and detailed picture that broadens our understanding of inter-American relations, not to mention the emergence of the fields of sociology, geography, history, archaeology, and political science. . . . Disciplinary Knowledge will be of interest to intellectual history specialists and historians of Latin America, and should be required reading for Latin American Studies instructors, who may be inclined to re-think the emphasis on outdated 'problems' in their teaching once they understand the genesis of the approach."
-- Amelia Kiddle Canadian Journal of History
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Acknowledgments ix
Introduction. Disciplinary Conquest 1
1. South America as a Field of Inquiry 17
2. Five Traveling Scholars 38
3. Research Designs of Transnational Scope 52
4. Yale at Machu Picchu: Hiram Bingham, Peruvian Indigenistas, and Cultural Property 75
5. Hispanic American History at Harvard: Clarence H. Haring and Regional History for Imperial Visibility 105
6. Intellectual Cooperation: Leo S. Rowe, Democratic Government, and the Politics of Scholarly Brotherhood 134
7. Geographic Conquest: Isaiah Bowman's View of South America 160
8. Worldly Sociology: Edward A. Ross and the Societies "South of Panama" 187
9. U.S. Scholars and the Queston of Empire 211
Conclusion 236
Notes 261
References 291
Index 313
REQUEST ACCESSIBLE FILE
If you are a student who cannot use this book in printed form, BiblioVault may be able to supply you
with an electronic file for alternative access.
Please have the accessibility coordinator at your school fill out this form.
Disciplinary Conquest: U.S. Scholars in South America, 1900–1945
by Ricardo D. Salvatore
Duke University Press, 2016 Paper: 978-0-8223-6095-7 Cloth: 978-0-8223-6081-0 eISBN: 978-0-8223-7450-3
In Disciplinary Conquest Ricardo D. Salvatore rewrites the origin story of Latin American studies by tracing the discipline's roots back to the first half of the twentieth century. Salvatore focuses on the work of five representative U.S. scholars of South America—historian Clarence Haring, geographer Isaiah Bowman, political scientist Leo Rowe, sociologist Edward Ross, and archaeologist Hiram Bingham—to show how Latin American studies was allied with U.S. business and foreign policy interests. Diplomats, policy makers, business investors, and the American public used the knowledge these and other scholars gathered to build an informal empire that fostered the growth of U.S. economic, technological, and cultural hegemony throughout the hemisphere. Tying the drive to know South America to the specialization and rise of Latin American studies, Salvatore shows how the disciplinary conquest of South America affirmed a new mode of American imperial engagement.
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY
Ricardo D. Salvatore is Plenary Professor at Universidad Torcuato Di Tella in Buenos Aires. He is the author of Wandering Paysanos: State Order and Subaltern Experience in Buenos Aires during the Rosas Era and coeditor of Crime and Punishment in Latin America: Law and Society Since Late Colonial Times, both also published by Duke University Press.
REVIEWS
"Not only a well-documented, nuanced, and challenging account, but also a rare and bold attempt to write the history of the hemisphere from South to North instead of from North to South, Disciplinary Conquest will hopefully be published also in Spanish and Portuguese and read by all practitioners in the field across the Americas and beyond."
-- Ori Preuss Journal of Latin American Studies
"This is a welcome and ambitious project that takes us into the empirical aspects of US-Latin American relations from the perspective of informal empires, with an original emphasis on the role of knowledge in the configuration of the powerful presence of the United States in the region. Extremely well documented and offering a narrative constructed from empirical data to make a point about hegemony, this book is a wonderful example of how situated knowledge can be explained in the structural context of inter-American relations."
-- H. Reuben Neptune American Historical Review
"Disciplinary Conquests offers an excellent and incisive account of U.S. scholars, their interest in (and relationship with) South America, and the links between the work of these scholars, empire, and foreign policy."
-- Evan C. Rothera Journal of Global South Studies
“[Salvatore] is, simply, a master raconteur. Disciplinary Conquest is essential reading for those with an interest in the evolution of inter-American relations.… It is a book that will assuredly warrant multiple rereadings.”
-- Philip Chrimes International Affairs
"Authoritatively written, [Disciplinary Conquest] is both theoretically valuable and empirically rich in detailed historical research, essential reading for understanding the crucial role of educational asymmetry and US universities in shaping thought leadership and hegemonic relations in the Western Hemisphere during the twentieth century. . . . A pleasure to read, each page with surprises that enrich the author’s project; readers will admire the meticulous detail of his research."
-- Edgar J. Dosman Latin American Research Review
"Disciplinary Conquest should be read by every scholar doing work in Latin America and teaching Latin American studies to undergraduate and graduate students. It is a valuable book that will promote intellectual debates about how we practice research and how our own aspirations lie within anything we write."
-- Yovanna Pineda The Latin Americanist
"Truly admirable in its scope and depth, Salvatore’s analysis provides a convincing and detailed picture that broadens our understanding of inter-American relations, not to mention the emergence of the fields of sociology, geography, history, archaeology, and political science. . . . Disciplinary Knowledge will be of interest to intellectual history specialists and historians of Latin America, and should be required reading for Latin American Studies instructors, who may be inclined to re-think the emphasis on outdated 'problems' in their teaching once they understand the genesis of the approach."
-- Amelia Kiddle Canadian Journal of History
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Acknowledgments ix
Introduction. Disciplinary Conquest 1
1. South America as a Field of Inquiry 17
2. Five Traveling Scholars 38
3. Research Designs of Transnational Scope 52
4. Yale at Machu Picchu: Hiram Bingham, Peruvian Indigenistas, and Cultural Property 75
5. Hispanic American History at Harvard: Clarence H. Haring and Regional History for Imperial Visibility 105
6. Intellectual Cooperation: Leo S. Rowe, Democratic Government, and the Politics of Scholarly Brotherhood 134
7. Geographic Conquest: Isaiah Bowman's View of South America 160
8. Worldly Sociology: Edward A. Ross and the Societies "South of Panama" 187
9. U.S. Scholars and the Queston of Empire 211
Conclusion 236
Notes 261
References 291
Index 313
REQUEST ACCESSIBLE FILE
If you are a student who cannot use this book in printed form, BiblioVault may be able to supply you
with an electronic file for alternative access.
Please have the accessibility coordinator at your school fill out this form.
It can take 2-3 weeks for requests to be filled.
ABOUT THIS BOOK | AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY | REVIEWS | TOC | REQUEST ACCESSIBLE FILE