Lasting Legacy to the Carolinas: The Duke Endowment, 1924–1994
by Robert F. Durden
Duke University Press, 1998 eISBN: 978-0-8223-9712-0 | Cloth: 978-0-8223-2151-4 Library of Congress Classification HV98.N82D853 1998 Dewey Decimal Classification 361.763209756
ABOUT THIS BOOK | AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY | REVIEWS | TOC | REQUEST ACCESSIBLE FILE
ABOUT THIS BOOK
Like the majority of the founders of large philanthropic foundations in the United States, James B. Duke assumed that the Duke Endowment, which he established in 1924, would continue its charitable activity forever. Lasting Legacy to the Carolinas is an examination of the history of this foundation and the ways in which it has—and has not—followed Duke’s original design.
In this volume, Robert F. Durden explores how the propriety of linking together a tax-free foundation and an investor-owned, profit-seeking business like the Duke Power Company has significantly changed over the course of the century. Explaining the implications of the Tax Reform Act of 1969 for J. B. Duke’s dream, Durden shows how the philanthropist’s plan to have the Duke Endowment virtually own and ultimately control Duke Power (which, in turn, would supply most of the Endowment’s income) dissolved after the death of daughter Doris Duke in 1993, when the trustees of the Endowment finally had the unanimous votes needed to sever that tie. Although the Endowment’s philanthropic projects—higher education (including Duke University), hospitals and health care, orphan and child care in both North and South Carolina, and the rural Methodist church in North Carolina—continue to be served, this study explains the impact of a century of political and social change on one man’s innovative charitable intentions. It is also a testimony to the many staff members and trustees who have invested their own time and creative energies into further benefiting these causes, despite decades of inevitable challenges to the Endowment.
This third volume of Durden’s trilogy relating to the Dukes of Durham will inform not only those interested in the continuing legacy of this remarkable family but also those involved with philanthropic boards, charitable endowments, medical care, child-care institutions, the rural church, and higher education.
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY
Robert F. Durden is Professor Emeritus of History at Duke University. He is the author of numerous books, including The Dukes of Durham and The Launching of Duke University, both published by Duke University Press.
REVIEWS
“Durden’s well-researched, straightforward account of the establishment of the Duke Endowment in 1924 and its evolution to 1994 is a solid contribution to the scholarly study of the ‘Philanthropoids’ who guide the power of philanthropy. . . . Respecting the fact that accuracy is complexity, Durden provides a good account of how difficult it is to do philanthropy well.” - Choice
“This is a substantial volume that, in addition to its heft, has a handsome look and feel to it. . . . [Durden’s] main thesis is that the history of the Duke Endowment shows that James B. Duke both succeeded and failed in his philanthropic efforts. . . . This volume is a worthy addition to [Durden’s] scholarship.” - Georgia Historical Quarterly
“[R]eaders interested in a thorough narrative of the formation and development of the Duke Endowment or wishing to learn more about any of the important subplots—including the history of higher education, the development of hospitals and medical care in the Carolinas, the evolution of the child care field, and the rural Methodist Church in North Carolina—will find Durden’s book a valuable resource.” - North Carolina Historical Review
"Lasting Legacy to the Carolinas presents new material that will be of use to the general public and to scholars interested in foundations and the history of the Carolinas. Durden is an excellent historian and writer."—Dr. P. Preston Reynolds, Welch Institute at The Johns Hopkins University
“[W]ell-organized and well-written. The author is especially adept at guiding the reader through the intricacies of Duke’s grand design and making understandable the dense verbiage of fiduciary law. Further, Durden provides useful historical sketches of several beneficiary institutions. Lasting Legacy to the Carolinas is a valuable addition to regional history and a fitting capstone to the study of a great family of the New South.” - Eldred E. Prince, Jr., Mississippi Quarterly
“Respecting the fact that accuracy is complexity, historian Durden carefully reveals a provocative account of how the personalities of the managers of philanthropy influenced the wielding of the wealth and the commitments of all of the institutions that the endowment touched. Durden has written a book that is needed in the history of wealth and education in the south. It is also a good account of how difficult it is to do philanthropy well.” - Journal of Southern History
“[R]eaders interested in a thorough narrative of the formation and development of the Duke Endowment or wishing to learn more about any of the important subplots—including the history of higher education, the development of hospitals and medical care in the Carolinas, the evolution of the child care field, and the rural Methodist Church in North Carolina—will find Durden’s book a valuable resource.”
-- North Carolina Historical Review
“[W]ell-organized and well-written. The author is especially adept at guiding the reader through the intricacies of Duke’s grand design and making understandable the dense verbiage of fiduciary law. Further, Durden provides useful historical sketches of several beneficiary institutions. Lasting Legacy to the Carolinas is a valuable addition to regional history and a fitting capstone to the study of a great family of the New South.”
-- Eldred E. Prince Jr. Mississippi Quarterly
“Durden’s well-researched, straightforward account of the establishment of the Duke Endowment in 1924 and its evolution to 1994 is a solid contribution to the scholarly study of the ‘Philanthropoids’ who guide the power of philanthropy. . . . Respecting the fact that accuracy is complexity, Durden provides a good account of how difficult it is to do philanthropy well.”
-- Choice
“Respecting the fact that accuracy is complexity, historian Durden carefully reveals a provocative account of how the personalities of the managers of philanthropy influenced the wielding of the wealth and the commitments of all of the institutions that the endowment touched. Durden has written a book that is needed in the history of wealth and education in the south. It is also a good account of how difficult it is to do philanthropy well.”
-- Journal of Southern History
“This is a substantial volume that, in addition to its heft, has a handsome look and feel to it. . . . [Durden’s] main thesis is that the history of the Duke Endowment shows that James B. Duke both succeeded and failed in his philanthropic efforts. . . . This volume is a worthy addition to [Durden’s] scholarship.”
-- Georgia Historical Quarterly
TABLE OF CONTENTS
4. The Endowment and the Four Educational Institutions, 1924-1960
Preface
1. The Origins of the Duke Endowment
2. Launching the Endowment: The Hospital and Orphan Section (Part 1)
3. Launching the Endowment: The Hospital and Orphan Section (Part 2)
5. In Remembrance of the Curcuit Riders: The Endowment and the Methodist Church in North Carolina, 1924-1960
6. Transitions and Troubles in the 1960s and 1970s
7. The Endowment and Its Educational Beneficiaries, 1960-1994
8. The Endowment and Hospitals, Child Care, and the Rural Methodist Church, 1960-1994
9. J. B. Duke Wins and Loses: The Partial Collapse of the Grand Design
Appendix 1: Trustees of the Duke Endowment
Appendix 2: Indenture and Deed of Trust of Personalty Establishing the Duke Endowment, December 11, 1924
A Note on Sources
Notes
Index
REQUEST ACCESSIBLE FILE
If you are a student who cannot use this book in printed form, BiblioVault may be able to supply you
with an electronic file for alternative access.
Please have the accessibility coordinator at your school fill out this form.
Lasting Legacy to the Carolinas: The Duke Endowment, 1924–1994
by Robert F. Durden
Duke University Press, 1998 eISBN: 978-0-8223-9712-0 Cloth: 978-0-8223-2151-4
Like the majority of the founders of large philanthropic foundations in the United States, James B. Duke assumed that the Duke Endowment, which he established in 1924, would continue its charitable activity forever. Lasting Legacy to the Carolinas is an examination of the history of this foundation and the ways in which it has—and has not—followed Duke’s original design.
In this volume, Robert F. Durden explores how the propriety of linking together a tax-free foundation and an investor-owned, profit-seeking business like the Duke Power Company has significantly changed over the course of the century. Explaining the implications of the Tax Reform Act of 1969 for J. B. Duke’s dream, Durden shows how the philanthropist’s plan to have the Duke Endowment virtually own and ultimately control Duke Power (which, in turn, would supply most of the Endowment’s income) dissolved after the death of daughter Doris Duke in 1993, when the trustees of the Endowment finally had the unanimous votes needed to sever that tie. Although the Endowment’s philanthropic projects—higher education (including Duke University), hospitals and health care, orphan and child care in both North and South Carolina, and the rural Methodist church in North Carolina—continue to be served, this study explains the impact of a century of political and social change on one man’s innovative charitable intentions. It is also a testimony to the many staff members and trustees who have invested their own time and creative energies into further benefiting these causes, despite decades of inevitable challenges to the Endowment.
This third volume of Durden’s trilogy relating to the Dukes of Durham will inform not only those interested in the continuing legacy of this remarkable family but also those involved with philanthropic boards, charitable endowments, medical care, child-care institutions, the rural church, and higher education.
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY
Robert F. Durden is Professor Emeritus of History at Duke University. He is the author of numerous books, including The Dukes of Durham and The Launching of Duke University, both published by Duke University Press.
REVIEWS
“Durden’s well-researched, straightforward account of the establishment of the Duke Endowment in 1924 and its evolution to 1994 is a solid contribution to the scholarly study of the ‘Philanthropoids’ who guide the power of philanthropy. . . . Respecting the fact that accuracy is complexity, Durden provides a good account of how difficult it is to do philanthropy well.” - Choice
“This is a substantial volume that, in addition to its heft, has a handsome look and feel to it. . . . [Durden’s] main thesis is that the history of the Duke Endowment shows that James B. Duke both succeeded and failed in his philanthropic efforts. . . . This volume is a worthy addition to [Durden’s] scholarship.” - Georgia Historical Quarterly
“[R]eaders interested in a thorough narrative of the formation and development of the Duke Endowment or wishing to learn more about any of the important subplots—including the history of higher education, the development of hospitals and medical care in the Carolinas, the evolution of the child care field, and the rural Methodist Church in North Carolina—will find Durden’s book a valuable resource.” - North Carolina Historical Review
"Lasting Legacy to the Carolinas presents new material that will be of use to the general public and to scholars interested in foundations and the history of the Carolinas. Durden is an excellent historian and writer."—Dr. P. Preston Reynolds, Welch Institute at The Johns Hopkins University
“[W]ell-organized and well-written. The author is especially adept at guiding the reader through the intricacies of Duke’s grand design and making understandable the dense verbiage of fiduciary law. Further, Durden provides useful historical sketches of several beneficiary institutions. Lasting Legacy to the Carolinas is a valuable addition to regional history and a fitting capstone to the study of a great family of the New South.” - Eldred E. Prince, Jr., Mississippi Quarterly
“Respecting the fact that accuracy is complexity, historian Durden carefully reveals a provocative account of how the personalities of the managers of philanthropy influenced the wielding of the wealth and the commitments of all of the institutions that the endowment touched. Durden has written a book that is needed in the history of wealth and education in the south. It is also a good account of how difficult it is to do philanthropy well.” - Journal of Southern History
“[R]eaders interested in a thorough narrative of the formation and development of the Duke Endowment or wishing to learn more about any of the important subplots—including the history of higher education, the development of hospitals and medical care in the Carolinas, the evolution of the child care field, and the rural Methodist Church in North Carolina—will find Durden’s book a valuable resource.”
-- North Carolina Historical Review
“[W]ell-organized and well-written. The author is especially adept at guiding the reader through the intricacies of Duke’s grand design and making understandable the dense verbiage of fiduciary law. Further, Durden provides useful historical sketches of several beneficiary institutions. Lasting Legacy to the Carolinas is a valuable addition to regional history and a fitting capstone to the study of a great family of the New South.”
-- Eldred E. Prince Jr. Mississippi Quarterly
“Durden’s well-researched, straightforward account of the establishment of the Duke Endowment in 1924 and its evolution to 1994 is a solid contribution to the scholarly study of the ‘Philanthropoids’ who guide the power of philanthropy. . . . Respecting the fact that accuracy is complexity, Durden provides a good account of how difficult it is to do philanthropy well.”
-- Choice
“Respecting the fact that accuracy is complexity, historian Durden carefully reveals a provocative account of how the personalities of the managers of philanthropy influenced the wielding of the wealth and the commitments of all of the institutions that the endowment touched. Durden has written a book that is needed in the history of wealth and education in the south. It is also a good account of how difficult it is to do philanthropy well.”
-- Journal of Southern History
“This is a substantial volume that, in addition to its heft, has a handsome look and feel to it. . . . [Durden’s] main thesis is that the history of the Duke Endowment shows that James B. Duke both succeeded and failed in his philanthropic efforts. . . . This volume is a worthy addition to [Durden’s] scholarship.”
-- Georgia Historical Quarterly
TABLE OF CONTENTS
4. The Endowment and the Four Educational Institutions, 1924-1960
Preface
1. The Origins of the Duke Endowment
2. Launching the Endowment: The Hospital and Orphan Section (Part 1)
3. Launching the Endowment: The Hospital and Orphan Section (Part 2)
5. In Remembrance of the Curcuit Riders: The Endowment and the Methodist Church in North Carolina, 1924-1960
6. Transitions and Troubles in the 1960s and 1970s
7. The Endowment and Its Educational Beneficiaries, 1960-1994
8. The Endowment and Hospitals, Child Care, and the Rural Methodist Church, 1960-1994
9. J. B. Duke Wins and Loses: The Partial Collapse of the Grand Design
Appendix 1: Trustees of the Duke Endowment
Appendix 2: Indenture and Deed of Trust of Personalty Establishing the Duke Endowment, December 11, 1924
A Note on Sources
Notes
Index
REQUEST ACCESSIBLE FILE
If you are a student who cannot use this book in printed form, BiblioVault may be able to supply you
with an electronic file for alternative access.
Please have the accessibility coordinator at your school fill out this form.
It can take 2-3 weeks for requests to be filled.
ABOUT THIS BOOK | AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY | REVIEWS | TOC | REQUEST ACCESSIBLE FILE