What Democracy Looks Like: The Rhetoric of Social Movements and Counterpublics
edited by Christina R. Foust, Amy Pason and Kate Zittlow Rogness contributions by Raymie E. McKerrow, Daniel C. Brouwer, Mary-Louise Paulesc, Catherine Helen Palczewski, Kelsey Harr-Lagin, Karma R. Chávez, Bernadette Marie Calafell, Dawn Marie D. McIntosh, Kevin Michael DeLuca, Elizabeth Brunner, Christina R. Foust, Catherine Chaput, Joshua S. Hanan, Amy Pason and Kate Zittlow Rogness introduction by Christina R. Foust, Amy Pason and Kate Zittlow Rogness
University of Alabama Press, 2017 Paper: 978-0-8173-5893-8 | eISBN: 978-0-8173-9118-8 Library of Congress Classification HM881.W47 2017 Dewey Decimal Classification 303.484
ABOUT THIS BOOK | AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY | REVIEWS | TOC
ABOUT THIS BOOK
What Democracy Looks Like is a compelling and timely collection which combines two distinct but related theories in rhetoric and communication studies, while also exploring theories and ideas espoused by those in sociology, political science, and cultural studies.
Recent protests around the world (such as the Arab Spring uprisings and Occupy Wall Street movements) have drawn renewed interest to the study of social change and, especially, to the manner in which words, images, events, and ideas associated with protestors can “move the social.” What Democracy Looks Like is an attempt to foster a more coherent understanding of social change among scholars of rhetoric and communication studies by juxtaposing the ideas of social movements and counterpublics—historically two key factors significant in the study of social change. Foust, Pason, and Zittlow Rogness’s volume compiles the voices of leading and new scholars who are contributing to the history, application, and new directions of these two concepts, all in conversation with a number of acts of resistance or social change.
The theories of social movements and counterpublics are related, but distinct. Social movement theories tend to be concerned with enacting policy and legislative changes. Scholars flying this flag have concentrated on the organization and language (for example, rallies and speeches) that are meant to enact social change. Counterpublic theory, on the other hand, focuses less on policy changes and more on the unequal distribution of power and resources among different protest groups, which is sometimes synonymous with subordinated identity groups such as race, gender, sexuality, and class.
Nonetheless, contributors argue that in recent years the distinctions between these two methods have become less evident. By putting the literatures of the two theories in conversation with one another, these scholars seek to promote and imagine social change outside the typical binaries.
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY
Christina R. Foust is an associate professor and chair of communication studies at the University of Denver and is the author of Transgression as a Mode of Resistance.
Amy Pason is an assistant professor of communication studies at the University of Nevada, Reno. Her work has appeared in the International Journal of Communication and ephemera.
Kate Zittlow Rogness teaches at Hamline University. Her work has appeared in First Amendment Studies and the Western Journal of Communication.
REVIEWS
" . . . beyond being timely, this collection also covers a vast amount of terrain, both through the range of scholarship, concepts, and key arguments discussed and the array of subject matter, sites of inquiry, and methodological frameworks brought into conversation within the individual case studies and analyses presented. As such, the answer to the question of whether it coheres 'a conversation on social change' and offers 'trajectories for future research in social change' is, in my opinion, decidedly yes. The chapters in this collection open up possibilities for future investigations into social movements and counterpublics through renewed, but complicated and overlapping, inquiries. . . . this collection offers a unique insight into social change approaches that many will find valuable."
—Rhetoric Review
"An impressive body of seminal and original scholarship, What Democracy Looks Like: The Rhetoric of Social Movements and Counterpublics is unreservedly recommended for both community and academic library Rhetoric, Communication Studies, and Social Science reference collections and supplemental studies lists."
—Midwest Book Review
“What Democracy Looks Like enables a kind of time travel by presenting for contemporary scholars a legacy of movement studies that may have been forgotten or ignored. Continuing through the present, the contributors present innovative studies that promise a bright future for scholarship on these topics.”
—Robert Asen, author of Democracy, Deliberation, and Education
— -
“This collection, featuring prominent authors in the field, usefully puts literatures in the areas of social movement and counterpublic studies (with its unique focus on circulation) in conversation with one another. The volume will stimulate discussion about the direction of social change research. This work is urgently needed as we try to understand not only how movement participants are working but also to articulate new ways of being in the world.”
—Dana L. Cloud, author of Control and Consolation in American Culture and Politics: Rhetorics of Therapy
— -
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Contents
Acknowledgments
Introduction: Rhetoric and the Study of Social Change / Amy Pason, Christina R. Foust, and Kate Zittlow Rogness
I. Problematizing the Past of Social Movement Rhetoric and Counterpublic Research
1. Social Movement Scholarship: A Retrospective/Prospective Review / Raymie E. McKerrow
2. “Social Movement Rhetoric”: A Critical Genealogy, Post-1980 / Christina R. Foust
3. Counterpublic Theory Goes Global: A Chronicle of a Concept’s Emergences and Mobilities / Daniel C. Brouwer and Marie-Louise Paulesc
II. Distinguishing and Performing Counterpublics and Movements through Case Studies
4. Phenomenon or Meaning? A Tale of Two Occupies / Amy Pason
5. Pledge-a-Picketer, Power, Protest, and Publicity: Explaining Protest When the State/Establishment Is Not the Opposition / Catherine Helen Palczewski and Kelsey Harr-Lagin
6. (Re)turning to the Private Sphere: SlutWalks’ Public Negotiation of Privacy / Kate Zittlow Rogness
7. Against Equality: Finding the Movement in Rhetorical Criticism of Social Movements / Karma R. Chávez with Yasmin Nair and Ryan Conrad
III. New Directions for Studying Social Movements and Counterpublics Rhetorically
8. Latina/o Vernacular Discourse: Theorizing Performative Dimensions of an Other Counterpublic / Bernadette Marie Calafell and Dawn Marie D. McIntosh
9. Activism in the Wake of the Events of China and Social Media: Abandoning the Domesticated Rituals of Democracy to Explore the Dangers of Wild Public Screens / Kevin Michael DeLuca and Elizabeth Brunner
10. WikiLeaks and Its Production of the Common: An Exploration of Rhetorical Agency in the Neoliberal Era / Catherine Chaput and Joshua S. Hanan
What Democracy Looks Like: The Rhetoric of Social Movements and Counterpublics
edited by Christina R. Foust, Amy Pason and Kate Zittlow Rogness contributions by Raymie E. McKerrow, Daniel C. Brouwer, Mary-Louise Paulesc, Catherine Helen Palczewski, Kelsey Harr-Lagin, Karma R. Chávez, Bernadette Marie Calafell, Dawn Marie D. McIntosh, Kevin Michael DeLuca, Elizabeth Brunner, Christina R. Foust, Catherine Chaput, Joshua S. Hanan, Amy Pason and Kate Zittlow Rogness introduction by Christina R. Foust, Amy Pason and Kate Zittlow Rogness
University of Alabama Press, 2017 Paper: 978-0-8173-5893-8 eISBN: 978-0-8173-9118-8
What Democracy Looks Like is a compelling and timely collection which combines two distinct but related theories in rhetoric and communication studies, while also exploring theories and ideas espoused by those in sociology, political science, and cultural studies.
Recent protests around the world (such as the Arab Spring uprisings and Occupy Wall Street movements) have drawn renewed interest to the study of social change and, especially, to the manner in which words, images, events, and ideas associated with protestors can “move the social.” What Democracy Looks Like is an attempt to foster a more coherent understanding of social change among scholars of rhetoric and communication studies by juxtaposing the ideas of social movements and counterpublics—historically two key factors significant in the study of social change. Foust, Pason, and Zittlow Rogness’s volume compiles the voices of leading and new scholars who are contributing to the history, application, and new directions of these two concepts, all in conversation with a number of acts of resistance or social change.
The theories of social movements and counterpublics are related, but distinct. Social movement theories tend to be concerned with enacting policy and legislative changes. Scholars flying this flag have concentrated on the organization and language (for example, rallies and speeches) that are meant to enact social change. Counterpublic theory, on the other hand, focuses less on policy changes and more on the unequal distribution of power and resources among different protest groups, which is sometimes synonymous with subordinated identity groups such as race, gender, sexuality, and class.
Nonetheless, contributors argue that in recent years the distinctions between these two methods have become less evident. By putting the literatures of the two theories in conversation with one another, these scholars seek to promote and imagine social change outside the typical binaries.
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY
Christina R. Foust is an associate professor and chair of communication studies at the University of Denver and is the author of Transgression as a Mode of Resistance.
Amy Pason is an assistant professor of communication studies at the University of Nevada, Reno. Her work has appeared in the International Journal of Communication and ephemera.
Kate Zittlow Rogness teaches at Hamline University. Her work has appeared in First Amendment Studies and the Western Journal of Communication.
REVIEWS
" . . . beyond being timely, this collection also covers a vast amount of terrain, both through the range of scholarship, concepts, and key arguments discussed and the array of subject matter, sites of inquiry, and methodological frameworks brought into conversation within the individual case studies and analyses presented. As such, the answer to the question of whether it coheres 'a conversation on social change' and offers 'trajectories for future research in social change' is, in my opinion, decidedly yes. The chapters in this collection open up possibilities for future investigations into social movements and counterpublics through renewed, but complicated and overlapping, inquiries. . . . this collection offers a unique insight into social change approaches that many will find valuable."
—Rhetoric Review
"An impressive body of seminal and original scholarship, What Democracy Looks Like: The Rhetoric of Social Movements and Counterpublics is unreservedly recommended for both community and academic library Rhetoric, Communication Studies, and Social Science reference collections and supplemental studies lists."
—Midwest Book Review
“What Democracy Looks Like enables a kind of time travel by presenting for contemporary scholars a legacy of movement studies that may have been forgotten or ignored. Continuing through the present, the contributors present innovative studies that promise a bright future for scholarship on these topics.”
—Robert Asen, author of Democracy, Deliberation, and Education
— -
“This collection, featuring prominent authors in the field, usefully puts literatures in the areas of social movement and counterpublic studies (with its unique focus on circulation) in conversation with one another. The volume will stimulate discussion about the direction of social change research. This work is urgently needed as we try to understand not only how movement participants are working but also to articulate new ways of being in the world.”
—Dana L. Cloud, author of Control and Consolation in American Culture and Politics: Rhetorics of Therapy
— -
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Contents
Acknowledgments
Introduction: Rhetoric and the Study of Social Change / Amy Pason, Christina R. Foust, and Kate Zittlow Rogness
I. Problematizing the Past of Social Movement Rhetoric and Counterpublic Research
1. Social Movement Scholarship: A Retrospective/Prospective Review / Raymie E. McKerrow
2. “Social Movement Rhetoric”: A Critical Genealogy, Post-1980 / Christina R. Foust
3. Counterpublic Theory Goes Global: A Chronicle of a Concept’s Emergences and Mobilities / Daniel C. Brouwer and Marie-Louise Paulesc
II. Distinguishing and Performing Counterpublics and Movements through Case Studies
4. Phenomenon or Meaning? A Tale of Two Occupies / Amy Pason
5. Pledge-a-Picketer, Power, Protest, and Publicity: Explaining Protest When the State/Establishment Is Not the Opposition / Catherine Helen Palczewski and Kelsey Harr-Lagin
6. (Re)turning to the Private Sphere: SlutWalks’ Public Negotiation of Privacy / Kate Zittlow Rogness
7. Against Equality: Finding the Movement in Rhetorical Criticism of Social Movements / Karma R. Chávez with Yasmin Nair and Ryan Conrad
III. New Directions for Studying Social Movements and Counterpublics Rhetorically
8. Latina/o Vernacular Discourse: Theorizing Performative Dimensions of an Other Counterpublic / Bernadette Marie Calafell and Dawn Marie D. McIntosh
9. Activism in the Wake of the Events of China and Social Media: Abandoning the Domesticated Rituals of Democracy to Explore the Dangers of Wild Public Screens / Kevin Michael DeLuca and Elizabeth Brunner
10. WikiLeaks and Its Production of the Common: An Exploration of Rhetorical Agency in the Neoliberal Era / Catherine Chaput and Joshua S. Hanan
Selected Bibliography
Contributors
Index
ABOUT THIS BOOK | AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY | REVIEWS | TOC