A Field on Fire: The Future of Environmental History
edited by Mark D. Hersey and Ted Steinberg contributions by Robert Wellman Campbell, Brian Allen Drake, Sterling Evans, Sara M. Gregg, Shen Hou, Neil M. Maher, Christof Mauch, Daniel T. Rodgers, Adam Rome, Edmund Russell, Mark D. Hersey, Mikko Saikku, Frank Zelko, Ted Steinberg, Marco Armiero, Kevin C. Armitage, Brian C. Black, Lisa M. Brady and Karl Boyd Brooks
University of Alabama Press, 2019 Cloth: 978-0-8173-2001-0 | eISBN: 978-0-8173-9208-6 Library of Congress Classification GF13+ Dewey Decimal Classification 304.2
ABOUT THIS BOOK | AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY | REVIEWS | TOC
ABOUT THIS BOOK
A frank and engaging exploration of the burgeoning academic field of environmental history
Inspired by the pioneering work of preeminent environmental historian Donald Worster, the contributors to A Field on Fire: The Future of Environmental History reflect on the past and future of this discipline. Featuring wide-ranging essays by leading environmental historians from the United States, Europe, and China, the collection challenges scholars to rethink some of their orthodoxies, inviting them to approach familiar stories from new angles, to integrate new methodologies, and to think creatively about the questions this field is well positioned to answer.
Worster’s groundbreaking research serves as the organizational framework for the collection. Editors Mark D. Hersey and Ted Steinberg have arranged the book into three sections corresponding to the primary concerns of Worster’s influential scholarship: the problem of natural limits, the transnational nature of environmental issues, and the question of method. Under the heading “Facing Limits,” five essays explore the inherent tensions between democracy, technology, capitalism, and the environment. The “Crossing Borders” section underscores the ways in which environmental history moves easily across national and disciplinary boundaries. Finally, “Doing Environmental History” invokes Worster’s work as an essayist by offering self-conscious reflections about the practice and purpose of environmental history.
The essays aim to provoke a discussion on the future of the field, pointing to untapped and underdeveloped avenues ripe for further exploration. A forward thinker like Worster presents bold challenges to a new generation of environmental historians on everything from capitalism and the Anthropocene to war and wilderness. This engaging volume includes a very special afterword by one of Worster’s oldest friends, the eminent intellectual historian Daniel Rodgers, who has known Worster for close to fifty years.
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY
Mark D. Hersey is associate professor of history at Mississippi State University where he directs the Center for the History of Agriculture, Science, and the Environment of the South. He is author of My Work Is That of Conservation: An Environmental Biography of George Washington Carver.
Ted Steinberg is Adeline Barry Davee Distinguished Professor of History and professor of law at Case Western Reserve University. He is the author of Gotham Unbound: The Ecological History of Greater New York; American Green: The Obsessive Quest for a Perfect Lawn; Down to Earth: Nature’s Role in American History; Acts of God: The Unnatural History of Natural Disaster in America; and Nature Incorporated; Industrialization and the Waters of New England.
REVIEWS
"These essays in honor of pioneer environmental historian Donald Worster are eye-openers. The authors call for transcending the perimeters of the discipline by drawing on new technologies and old concepts, and by using both global and local scales of inquiry, all with a sense of manifest urgency. Three sections deal with Worster’s main concerns: nature’s limits, the need to overcome artificial boundaries, and a "green" historical method. New explorations of the effects of emigration, the possibilities GIS offers historians, and non-Western approaches are explored. One essay takes a micro-look at the environmental degradation of Malibu; another calls for a macro-look at our planet from space. The useful introduction and afterword tie the text together. Perspectives offered by ecofeminism and ecoanarchism are not considered, however. All 17 essays share common assumptions: historians have neglected the intricacies of the nature/human nexus; our civilization is now bumping up against nature’s limits; our activities can have unintended consequences; the primary culprit in the ecological crisis is capitalism; rigid academic boundaries have stifled useful analysis; both science and the humanities require a new axiology; and above all, we don’t have much time left to get it right. Recommended."
—CHOICE
"A Field on Fire is an engaging volume that includes a very special afterword by one of Worster's oldest friends, the eminent intellectual historian Daniel Rodgers, who has known Worster for close to fifty years."
—Midwest Book Review
"Like a good prairie fire, the essays in this uniformly excellent collection seek to rejuvenate the field of environmental history, allowing its radical origins to regreen and sprout anew. A Field on Fire is a fitting tribute to Donald Worster’s remarkable career as an historical innovator who insisted that our ethical responsibilities extended well beyond the human community."
—Paul S. Sutter, University of Colorado Boulder
"Every so often, practitioners unfold their maps to access the whereabouts and forward movement of their field of study. The contributors to this outstanding collection point to smart new directions for environmental history. Doing so, while also writing with verve and insight, they pay tribute to the field’s most distinguished and agile pathfinder, Donald Worster."
—Jack Davis, author of Gulf: The Making of an American Sea, winner of the 2018 Pulitzer Prize for History
“A fun, thought-provoking read penned by some of the most talented environmental historians in the field.”
—Bartow J. Elmore, author of Citizen Coke: The Making of Coca-Cola Capitalism
— -
“The essays in A Field on Fire examine new trends in environmental history and will interest environmental historians, geographers, and historians of science and technology.”
—Lisa Mighetto, author of Wild Animals and American Environmental Ethics and executive director of the American Society for Environmental History
“A Field on Fire reveals the extent to which Donald Worster’s influence has shaped the currents of environmental history as well as agricultural history. These essays offer just the set of walking shoes that we will need for the work ahead.”
—Agricultural History
— -
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Contents
List of Illustrations
Introduction: A Good Set of Walking Shoes by Mark D. Hersey
Part I. Facing Limits
Chapter 1. Subversive Subjects: Donald Worster and the Radical Origins of Environmental History by Ted Steinberg
Chapter 2. Can Capitalism Ever Be Green? by Adam Rome
Chapter 3. Seeing Like a God: Environmentalism in the Anthropocene by Frank Zelko
Chapter 4. The Locked Door: Thomas Midgley Jr., Chlorofluorocarbons, and the Unintended Consequences of Technology by Kevin C. Armitage
Chapter 5. Malibu, California: Edenic Illusions and Natural Disasters by Christof Mauch
Chapter 6. Energizing Environmental History by Brian C. Black
Part II. World without Borders
Chapter 7. The Force of Fiber: Reconnecting the Philippines with Latin America and the American West via Transnational Environmental History by Sterling Evans
Chapter 8. Hunting and Wilderness in the Creation of National Identities by Mikko Saikku
Chapter 9. Why We Need Comparative History: The Case of China and the United States by Shen Hou
Chapter 10. The World in a Tin Can: Migrants in Environmental History by Marco Armiero
Chapter 11. Down in the Sky: The Promise of Aerial Environmental History by Robert Wellman Campbell
Chapter 12. Rivers of Dust: An Environmental Historian Appraises the American Legal System by Karl Boyd Brooks
Part III. Doing Environmental History
Chapter 13. Whole Earth without Borders: Earth Photographs, Space Data, and the Importance of Visual Culture within Environmental History by Neil M. Maher
Chapter 14. Beyond Stories: Geospatial Influences on the Practice of Environmental History by Sara M. Gregg
Chapter 15. Low-Hanging Fruit: Science and Environmental History by Edmund Russell
Chapter 16. The Watershed of War: Environmental History and the “Big Civil War” by Brian Allen Drake
Chapter 17. War from the Ground Up: Integrating Military and Environmental Histories by Lisa M. Brady
Afterword: The Distinctiveness of Environmental History by Daniel T. Rodgers
A Field on Fire: The Future of Environmental History
edited by Mark D. Hersey and Ted Steinberg contributions by Robert Wellman Campbell, Brian Allen Drake, Sterling Evans, Sara M. Gregg, Shen Hou, Neil M. Maher, Christof Mauch, Daniel T. Rodgers, Adam Rome, Edmund Russell, Mark D. Hersey, Mikko Saikku, Frank Zelko, Ted Steinberg, Marco Armiero, Kevin C. Armitage, Brian C. Black, Lisa M. Brady and Karl Boyd Brooks
University of Alabama Press, 2019 Cloth: 978-0-8173-2001-0 eISBN: 978-0-8173-9208-6
A frank and engaging exploration of the burgeoning academic field of environmental history
Inspired by the pioneering work of preeminent environmental historian Donald Worster, the contributors to A Field on Fire: The Future of Environmental History reflect on the past and future of this discipline. Featuring wide-ranging essays by leading environmental historians from the United States, Europe, and China, the collection challenges scholars to rethink some of their orthodoxies, inviting them to approach familiar stories from new angles, to integrate new methodologies, and to think creatively about the questions this field is well positioned to answer.
Worster’s groundbreaking research serves as the organizational framework for the collection. Editors Mark D. Hersey and Ted Steinberg have arranged the book into three sections corresponding to the primary concerns of Worster’s influential scholarship: the problem of natural limits, the transnational nature of environmental issues, and the question of method. Under the heading “Facing Limits,” five essays explore the inherent tensions between democracy, technology, capitalism, and the environment. The “Crossing Borders” section underscores the ways in which environmental history moves easily across national and disciplinary boundaries. Finally, “Doing Environmental History” invokes Worster’s work as an essayist by offering self-conscious reflections about the practice and purpose of environmental history.
The essays aim to provoke a discussion on the future of the field, pointing to untapped and underdeveloped avenues ripe for further exploration. A forward thinker like Worster presents bold challenges to a new generation of environmental historians on everything from capitalism and the Anthropocene to war and wilderness. This engaging volume includes a very special afterword by one of Worster’s oldest friends, the eminent intellectual historian Daniel Rodgers, who has known Worster for close to fifty years.
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY
Mark D. Hersey is associate professor of history at Mississippi State University where he directs the Center for the History of Agriculture, Science, and the Environment of the South. He is author of My Work Is That of Conservation: An Environmental Biography of George Washington Carver.
Ted Steinberg is Adeline Barry Davee Distinguished Professor of History and professor of law at Case Western Reserve University. He is the author of Gotham Unbound: The Ecological History of Greater New York; American Green: The Obsessive Quest for a Perfect Lawn; Down to Earth: Nature’s Role in American History; Acts of God: The Unnatural History of Natural Disaster in America; and Nature Incorporated; Industrialization and the Waters of New England.
REVIEWS
"These essays in honor of pioneer environmental historian Donald Worster are eye-openers. The authors call for transcending the perimeters of the discipline by drawing on new technologies and old concepts, and by using both global and local scales of inquiry, all with a sense of manifest urgency. Three sections deal with Worster’s main concerns: nature’s limits, the need to overcome artificial boundaries, and a "green" historical method. New explorations of the effects of emigration, the possibilities GIS offers historians, and non-Western approaches are explored. One essay takes a micro-look at the environmental degradation of Malibu; another calls for a macro-look at our planet from space. The useful introduction and afterword tie the text together. Perspectives offered by ecofeminism and ecoanarchism are not considered, however. All 17 essays share common assumptions: historians have neglected the intricacies of the nature/human nexus; our civilization is now bumping up against nature’s limits; our activities can have unintended consequences; the primary culprit in the ecological crisis is capitalism; rigid academic boundaries have stifled useful analysis; both science and the humanities require a new axiology; and above all, we don’t have much time left to get it right. Recommended."
—CHOICE
"A Field on Fire is an engaging volume that includes a very special afterword by one of Worster's oldest friends, the eminent intellectual historian Daniel Rodgers, who has known Worster for close to fifty years."
—Midwest Book Review
"Like a good prairie fire, the essays in this uniformly excellent collection seek to rejuvenate the field of environmental history, allowing its radical origins to regreen and sprout anew. A Field on Fire is a fitting tribute to Donald Worster’s remarkable career as an historical innovator who insisted that our ethical responsibilities extended well beyond the human community."
—Paul S. Sutter, University of Colorado Boulder
"Every so often, practitioners unfold their maps to access the whereabouts and forward movement of their field of study. The contributors to this outstanding collection point to smart new directions for environmental history. Doing so, while also writing with verve and insight, they pay tribute to the field’s most distinguished and agile pathfinder, Donald Worster."
—Jack Davis, author of Gulf: The Making of an American Sea, winner of the 2018 Pulitzer Prize for History
“A fun, thought-provoking read penned by some of the most talented environmental historians in the field.”
—Bartow J. Elmore, author of Citizen Coke: The Making of Coca-Cola Capitalism
— -
“The essays in A Field on Fire examine new trends in environmental history and will interest environmental historians, geographers, and historians of science and technology.”
—Lisa Mighetto, author of Wild Animals and American Environmental Ethics and executive director of the American Society for Environmental History
“A Field on Fire reveals the extent to which Donald Worster’s influence has shaped the currents of environmental history as well as agricultural history. These essays offer just the set of walking shoes that we will need for the work ahead.”
—Agricultural History
— -
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Contents
List of Illustrations
Introduction: A Good Set of Walking Shoes by Mark D. Hersey
Part I. Facing Limits
Chapter 1. Subversive Subjects: Donald Worster and the Radical Origins of Environmental History by Ted Steinberg
Chapter 2. Can Capitalism Ever Be Green? by Adam Rome
Chapter 3. Seeing Like a God: Environmentalism in the Anthropocene by Frank Zelko
Chapter 4. The Locked Door: Thomas Midgley Jr., Chlorofluorocarbons, and the Unintended Consequences of Technology by Kevin C. Armitage
Chapter 5. Malibu, California: Edenic Illusions and Natural Disasters by Christof Mauch
Chapter 6. Energizing Environmental History by Brian C. Black
Part II. World without Borders
Chapter 7. The Force of Fiber: Reconnecting the Philippines with Latin America and the American West via Transnational Environmental History by Sterling Evans
Chapter 8. Hunting and Wilderness in the Creation of National Identities by Mikko Saikku
Chapter 9. Why We Need Comparative History: The Case of China and the United States by Shen Hou
Chapter 10. The World in a Tin Can: Migrants in Environmental History by Marco Armiero
Chapter 11. Down in the Sky: The Promise of Aerial Environmental History by Robert Wellman Campbell
Chapter 12. Rivers of Dust: An Environmental Historian Appraises the American Legal System by Karl Boyd Brooks
Part III. Doing Environmental History
Chapter 13. Whole Earth without Borders: Earth Photographs, Space Data, and the Importance of Visual Culture within Environmental History by Neil M. Maher
Chapter 14. Beyond Stories: Geospatial Influences on the Practice of Environmental History by Sara M. Gregg
Chapter 15. Low-Hanging Fruit: Science and Environmental History by Edmund Russell
Chapter 16. The Watershed of War: Environmental History and the “Big Civil War” by Brian Allen Drake
Chapter 17. War from the Ground Up: Integrating Military and Environmental Histories by Lisa M. Brady
Afterword: The Distinctiveness of Environmental History by Daniel T. Rodgers
Bibliography
About the Contributors
Index
ABOUT THIS BOOK | AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY | REVIEWS | TOC