Philadelphia and the Development of Americanist Archaeology
edited by Don D. Fowler and David R. Wilcox contributions by David J. Meltzer, Frances Joan Mathien, Eleanor M . King, Regna Darnell, Steven Conn, Jerald T. Milanich, Don D. Fowler, Jeremy A. Sabloff, David R. Wilcox, Lawrence E. Aten, Elin C. Danien, Robert L. Schuyler and Curtis M. Hinsley
University of Alabama Press, 2003 Paper: 978-0-8173-1312-8 | eISBN: 978-0-8173-8463-0 | Cloth: 978-0-8173-1311-1 Library of Congress Classification GN17.3.U6P48 2003 Dewey Decimal Classification 974.801
ABOUT THIS BOOK | AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY | REVIEWS | TOC
ABOUT THIS BOOK
For two and a half centuries, Philadelphians have been actively involved in archaeological research. In particular, three vital and venerable cultural institutions—the American Philosophical Society (founded 1743), the Academy of Natural Sciences (founded 1812), and the University Museum of the University of Pennsylvania (founded 1893)—have nurtured the "systematic study of antiquities."
The ten essays in this volume focus on Philadelphians who were concerned with Americanist archaeology, or the "archaeology of the New World." As Europeans, and later, Euroamericans, spread across North, Central, and South America in the 16th through the 19th centuries, they encountered a bewildering variety of native peoples, customs, and languages, as well as tens of thousands of ancient ruins attesting to a long endemic culture history of obvious complexity.
The essays examine most of the key players in the development of the methods to study these phenomena. Enlightenment scholars such as Benjamin Smith Barton, Peter S. Duponceau, Thomas Jefferson, Daniel Garrison Brinton, John Wesley Powell, and Benjamin Rush all contributed to the surge of scientific study of America's prehistoric cultures. So did two pioneering women who have received scant attention to date—Sara Yorke Stevenson and Lucy W. Wilson—but whose work is well treated in this study. Other essays detail the varied contributions of C. C. Abbott, Frank Hamilton Cushing, Clarence B. Moore, Edgar Lee Hewett, and John L. Cotter. This volume should stimulate continued interest in the origins and history of archaeology and the relationship of Philadelphia patrons and institutions to scientific inquiry.
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY
Don D. Fowler is Professor of Anthropology at the University of Nevada, Reno, and author of American Archaeology: Past and Present.
David R. Wilcox is Senior Curator of Anthropology at the Museum of Northern Arizona in Flagstaff and coeditor of The Last Itinerary of Frank Hamilton Cushing.
REVIEWS
"That Philadelphia played a role in the birth of both our nation and our discipline is a significant correlation. How the people considered in this book contributed to their world and therefore to ours is a story worth telling." —Current Anthropology
"Of particular interest to students of the history of science, American archaeologists, and New England social historians. . . . Recommended. All levels and collections. —CHOICE
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Contents
List of Illustrations
Foreword by Jeremy A. Sabloff
Introduction by Don D. Fowler and David R. Wilcox
1. Drab Doves Take Flight: The Dilemmas of Early Americanist Archaeology in Philadelphia, 1889-1900 by Curtis M. Hinsley
2. Toward Consensus on the Scope of Anthropology: Daniel Garrison Brinton and the View from Philadelphia by Regna Darnell
3. Unsung Visionary: Sara Yoke Stevenson and the Development of Archaeology in Philadelphia by Elin C. Danien and Eleanor M. King
4. In the Heat of Controversy: C.C. Abbott, the American Paleolithic, and the University Museum, 1889-1893 by David J. Meltzer
5. Restoring Authenticity: Judging Frank Hamilton Cushing's Veracity by David R. Wilcox
6. Clarence Bloomfield Moore: A Philadelphia Archaeologist in the Southeastern United States by Lawrence E. Aten and Jerald T. Milanich
7. Lucy L. Wilson, Ph.D.: An Eastern Educator and the Southwestern Pueblos by Frances Joan Mathien
8. The Second Largest City in the English-Speaking World: John L. Cotter and the Historical Archaeology of Philadelphia, 1960-1999 by Robert L. Schuyler
9. Archaeology, Philadelphia, and Understanding Nineteenth-Century American Culture by Steven Conn
Philadelphia and the Development of Americanist Archaeology
edited by Don D. Fowler and David R. Wilcox contributions by David J. Meltzer, Frances Joan Mathien, Eleanor M . King, Regna Darnell, Steven Conn, Jerald T. Milanich, Don D. Fowler, Jeremy A. Sabloff, David R. Wilcox, Lawrence E. Aten, Elin C. Danien, Robert L. Schuyler and Curtis M. Hinsley
University of Alabama Press, 2003 Paper: 978-0-8173-1312-8 eISBN: 978-0-8173-8463-0 Cloth: 978-0-8173-1311-1
For two and a half centuries, Philadelphians have been actively involved in archaeological research. In particular, three vital and venerable cultural institutions—the American Philosophical Society (founded 1743), the Academy of Natural Sciences (founded 1812), and the University Museum of the University of Pennsylvania (founded 1893)—have nurtured the "systematic study of antiquities."
The ten essays in this volume focus on Philadelphians who were concerned with Americanist archaeology, or the "archaeology of the New World." As Europeans, and later, Euroamericans, spread across North, Central, and South America in the 16th through the 19th centuries, they encountered a bewildering variety of native peoples, customs, and languages, as well as tens of thousands of ancient ruins attesting to a long endemic culture history of obvious complexity.
The essays examine most of the key players in the development of the methods to study these phenomena. Enlightenment scholars such as Benjamin Smith Barton, Peter S. Duponceau, Thomas Jefferson, Daniel Garrison Brinton, John Wesley Powell, and Benjamin Rush all contributed to the surge of scientific study of America's prehistoric cultures. So did two pioneering women who have received scant attention to date—Sara Yorke Stevenson and Lucy W. Wilson—but whose work is well treated in this study. Other essays detail the varied contributions of C. C. Abbott, Frank Hamilton Cushing, Clarence B. Moore, Edgar Lee Hewett, and John L. Cotter. This volume should stimulate continued interest in the origins and history of archaeology and the relationship of Philadelphia patrons and institutions to scientific inquiry.
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY
Don D. Fowler is Professor of Anthropology at the University of Nevada, Reno, and author of American Archaeology: Past and Present.
David R. Wilcox is Senior Curator of Anthropology at the Museum of Northern Arizona in Flagstaff and coeditor of The Last Itinerary of Frank Hamilton Cushing.
REVIEWS
"That Philadelphia played a role in the birth of both our nation and our discipline is a significant correlation. How the people considered in this book contributed to their world and therefore to ours is a story worth telling." —Current Anthropology
"Of particular interest to students of the history of science, American archaeologists, and New England social historians. . . . Recommended. All levels and collections. —CHOICE
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Contents
List of Illustrations
Foreword by Jeremy A. Sabloff
Introduction by Don D. Fowler and David R. Wilcox
1. Drab Doves Take Flight: The Dilemmas of Early Americanist Archaeology in Philadelphia, 1889-1900 by Curtis M. Hinsley
2. Toward Consensus on the Scope of Anthropology: Daniel Garrison Brinton and the View from Philadelphia by Regna Darnell
3. Unsung Visionary: Sara Yoke Stevenson and the Development of Archaeology in Philadelphia by Elin C. Danien and Eleanor M. King
4. In the Heat of Controversy: C.C. Abbott, the American Paleolithic, and the University Museum, 1889-1893 by David J. Meltzer
5. Restoring Authenticity: Judging Frank Hamilton Cushing's Veracity by David R. Wilcox
6. Clarence Bloomfield Moore: A Philadelphia Archaeologist in the Southeastern United States by Lawrence E. Aten and Jerald T. Milanich
7. Lucy L. Wilson, Ph.D.: An Eastern Educator and the Southwestern Pueblos by Frances Joan Mathien
8. The Second Largest City in the English-Speaking World: John L. Cotter and the Historical Archaeology of Philadelphia, 1960-1999 by Robert L. Schuyler
9. Archaeology, Philadelphia, and Understanding Nineteenth-Century American Culture by Steven Conn
10. Philarivalium by Alice Beck Kehoe
Appendix
References
Contributors
Index
ABOUT THIS BOOK | AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY | REVIEWS | TOC