Engaged Observer: Anthropology, Advocacy, and Activism
edited by Victoria Sanford and Asale Angel-Ajani by Shannon Speed, Dana-Ain Davis, Michael Bosia, Roberta Culbertson, John Collins, Aldo Civico, Kay Warren, Asale Angel-Ajani, Victoria Sanford, Phillippe Bourgois, Irina Carlota Silber, Rosalva Aida Hernandez Castillo and Dr. Monique Skidmore foreword by Phillippe Bourgois
Rutgers University Press, 2006 Cloth: 978-0-8135-3891-4 | Paper: 978-0-8135-3892-1 Library of Congress Classification GN33.E65 2006 Dewey Decimal Classification 301.01
ABOUT THIS BOOK | AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY | TOC
ABOUT THIS BOOK
Anthropology has long been associated with an ethos of “engagement.” The field’s core methods and practices involve long-term interpersonal contact between researchers and their study participants, giving major research topics in the field a distinctively human face. Can research findings be authentic and objective? Are anthropologists able to use their data to aid the participants of their study, and is that aid always welcome?
In Engaged Observer, Victoria Sanford and Asale Angel-Ajani bring together an international array of scholars who have been embedded in some of the most conflict-ridden and dangerous zones in the world to reflect on the role and responsibility of anthropological inquiry. They explore issues of truth and objectivity, the role of the academic, the politics of memory, and the impact of race, gender, and social position on the research process. Through ethnographic case studies, they offer models for conducting engaged research and illustrate the contradictions and challenges of doing so.
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY
Victoria Sanford is an assistant professor of anthropology at Lehman College, CUNY. Asale Angel-Ajani is an assistant professor in the Gallatin School at New York University.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Contents
Foreword Philippe Bourgois
Acknowledgments
Introduction Victoria Sanford
Part I-The Politics of Witnessing in War and Pain
Chapter One: Excavations of the Heart: Reflections on Truth, Memory, and Structures of Understanding
Victoria Sanford
Chapter Two: Scholarship, Advocacy, and the Politics of Engagement in Burma (Myanmar)
Monique Skidmore
Chapter Three: War and the Nature of Ultimate Things: An Essay on the Study of Postwar Cultures
Roberta Culbertson
Chapter Four: Expert Witness: Notes Toward Revisiting the Politics of Listening
Asale Angel-Ajani
Part II-Lessons from Agents of Change
Chapter Five: Moral Chronologies: Generation and Popular Memory in a Palestinian Refugee Camp
John Collins
Chapter Six: "In Our Beds and Our Graves"-Revealing the Politics of Pleasure and Pain in the Time of AIDS
Michael J. Bosia
Chapter Seven: Portrait of a Paramilitary-Putting a Human Face on the Colombian Conflict
Aldo Civico
Part III-Trauma, Violence, and Women's Resistance in Everyday Life
Chapter Eight: Indigenous Women and Gendered Resistance in the Wake of Acteal: A Feminist Activist Research Perspective
Shannon Speed
Chapter Nine: Fratricidal War or Ethnocidal Strategy? Women's Experience with Political Violence in Chiapas
R. Aida Hernandez Castillo
Chapter Ten: It's a Hard Place to be a Revolutionary Woman: Finding Peace and Justice in Postwar El Salvador
Irina Carlota Silber
Part IV-The Engaged Observer: Inside and Outside the Academy
Chapter Eleven: Perils and Promises of Engaged Anthropology:
Historical Transitions and Ethnographic Dilemmas
Kay B. Warren
Chapter Twelve: Knowledge in the Service of a Vision: Notes from a Politically Engaged Anthropologist
Dana-Ain Davis
Notes
Bibliography
Contributor Biographies
Index
Engaged Observer: Anthropology, Advocacy, and Activism
edited by Victoria Sanford and Asale Angel-Ajani by Shannon Speed, Dana-Ain Davis, Michael Bosia, Roberta Culbertson, John Collins, Aldo Civico, Kay Warren, Asale Angel-Ajani, Victoria Sanford, Phillippe Bourgois, Irina Carlota Silber, Rosalva Aida Hernandez Castillo and Dr. Monique Skidmore foreword by Phillippe Bourgois
Rutgers University Press, 2006 Cloth: 978-0-8135-3891-4 Paper: 978-0-8135-3892-1
Anthropology has long been associated with an ethos of “engagement.” The field’s core methods and practices involve long-term interpersonal contact between researchers and their study participants, giving major research topics in the field a distinctively human face. Can research findings be authentic and objective? Are anthropologists able to use their data to aid the participants of their study, and is that aid always welcome?
In Engaged Observer, Victoria Sanford and Asale Angel-Ajani bring together an international array of scholars who have been embedded in some of the most conflict-ridden and dangerous zones in the world to reflect on the role and responsibility of anthropological inquiry. They explore issues of truth and objectivity, the role of the academic, the politics of memory, and the impact of race, gender, and social position on the research process. Through ethnographic case studies, they offer models for conducting engaged research and illustrate the contradictions and challenges of doing so.
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY
Victoria Sanford is an assistant professor of anthropology at Lehman College, CUNY. Asale Angel-Ajani is an assistant professor in the Gallatin School at New York University.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Contents
Foreword Philippe Bourgois
Acknowledgments
Introduction Victoria Sanford
Part I-The Politics of Witnessing in War and Pain
Chapter One: Excavations of the Heart: Reflections on Truth, Memory, and Structures of Understanding
Victoria Sanford
Chapter Two: Scholarship, Advocacy, and the Politics of Engagement in Burma (Myanmar)
Monique Skidmore
Chapter Three: War and the Nature of Ultimate Things: An Essay on the Study of Postwar Cultures
Roberta Culbertson
Chapter Four: Expert Witness: Notes Toward Revisiting the Politics of Listening
Asale Angel-Ajani
Part II-Lessons from Agents of Change
Chapter Five: Moral Chronologies: Generation and Popular Memory in a Palestinian Refugee Camp
John Collins
Chapter Six: "In Our Beds and Our Graves"-Revealing the Politics of Pleasure and Pain in the Time of AIDS
Michael J. Bosia
Chapter Seven: Portrait of a Paramilitary-Putting a Human Face on the Colombian Conflict
Aldo Civico
Part III-Trauma, Violence, and Women's Resistance in Everyday Life
Chapter Eight: Indigenous Women and Gendered Resistance in the Wake of Acteal: A Feminist Activist Research Perspective
Shannon Speed
Chapter Nine: Fratricidal War or Ethnocidal Strategy? Women's Experience with Political Violence in Chiapas
R. Aida Hernandez Castillo
Chapter Ten: It's a Hard Place to be a Revolutionary Woman: Finding Peace and Justice in Postwar El Salvador
Irina Carlota Silber
Part IV-The Engaged Observer: Inside and Outside the Academy
Chapter Eleven: Perils and Promises of Engaged Anthropology:
Historical Transitions and Ethnographic Dilemmas
Kay B. Warren
Chapter Twelve: Knowledge in the Service of a Vision: Notes from a Politically Engaged Anthropologist
Dana-Ain Davis
Notes
Bibliography
Contributor Biographies
Index