What Is China?: Territory, Ethnicity, Culture, and History
by Zhaoguang Ge translated by Michael Gibbs Hill
Harvard University Press, 2018 eISBN: 978-0-674-98500-1 | Cloth: 978-0-674-73714-3 Library of Congress Classification DS735.G44913 2018 Dewey Decimal Classification 951
ABOUT THIS BOOK | REVIEWS | TOC
ABOUT THIS BOOK
Ge Zhaoguang, an eminent historian of traditional China and a public intellectual, takes on fundamental questions that shape the domestic and international politics of the world’s most populous country and its second largest economy. What Is China? offers an insider’s account that addresses sensitive problems of Chinese identity and shows how modern scholarship about China—whether conducted in China, East Asia, or the West—has attempted to make sense of the country’s shifting territorial boundaries and its diversity of ethnic groups and cultures.
Ge considers, for example, the ancient concept of tianxia, or All-Under-Heaven, which assigned supremacy to the imperial court and lesser status to officials, citizens, tributary states, and tribal peoples. Does China’s government still operate with a belief in divine rule of All-Under-Heaven, or has it taken a different view of other actors, inside and outside its current borders? Responding both to Western theories of the nation-state and to Chinese intellectuals eager to promote “national learning,” Ge offers an insightful and erudite account of how China sees its place in the world. As he wrestles with complex historical and cultural forces guiding the inner workings of an often misunderstood nation, Ge also teases out many nuances of China’s encounter with the contemporary world, using China’s past to explain aspects of its present and to provide insight into various paths the nation might follow as the twenty-first century unfolds.
REVIEWS
This erudite polemic targets the aggressive nationalism that is widespread in China today.
-- Andrew J. Nathan Foreign Affairs
This book is remarkable. It helps us see how the Chinese see themselves, addressing issues such as China’s borders, its relations with its neighbors, and the notion that China and the West are on a collision course. Ge is not defending or attacking anything, but wants to talk to us about where China is with respect to the world, by thinking historically, by relativizing where we all find ourselves now. Sabre-rattlers on all sides, beware.
-- Timothy Brook, University of British Columbia
Non-Chinese speakers have far too little access to the opinions of Chinese intellectuals today. This book gives an excellent overview of the main issues that lie behind the conundrum of a modern Chinese identity. Ge’s voice is one that most definitely needs to be heard by everyone in the West who ‘worries about China.’
-- Mark C. Elliott, Harvard University
There is much to be learned from this critically engaged, liberal-minded, historically informed questioning from within China of Chinese national identity… Most importantly, What Is China? provides English-language readers with access to a thoughtful attempt to answer that question by a respected and influential Chinese scholar.
-- Richard Belsky Pacific Affairs
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Cover
Title Page
Copyright
Contents
Preface
Translator’s Introduction
Introduction: On the Historical Formation of “China” and the Dilemma of Chinese Identity
1. Worldviews: From “All-under-Heaven” in Ancient China to the “Myriad States” in the Modern World
2. Borders: On “Chinese” Territory
3. Ethnicity: Including the “Four Barbarians” in “China”?
4. History: Chinese Culture from a Long-Term Perspective
5. Peripheries: How China, Korea, and Japan Have Understood One Another since the Sixteenth and Seventeenth Centuries
6. Practical Questions: Will Cultural Differences between China and the West Lead to Conflict?
What Is China?: Territory, Ethnicity, Culture, and History
by Zhaoguang Ge translated by Michael Gibbs Hill
Harvard University Press, 2018 eISBN: 978-0-674-98500-1 Cloth: 978-0-674-73714-3
Ge Zhaoguang, an eminent historian of traditional China and a public intellectual, takes on fundamental questions that shape the domestic and international politics of the world’s most populous country and its second largest economy. What Is China? offers an insider’s account that addresses sensitive problems of Chinese identity and shows how modern scholarship about China—whether conducted in China, East Asia, or the West—has attempted to make sense of the country’s shifting territorial boundaries and its diversity of ethnic groups and cultures.
Ge considers, for example, the ancient concept of tianxia, or All-Under-Heaven, which assigned supremacy to the imperial court and lesser status to officials, citizens, tributary states, and tribal peoples. Does China’s government still operate with a belief in divine rule of All-Under-Heaven, or has it taken a different view of other actors, inside and outside its current borders? Responding both to Western theories of the nation-state and to Chinese intellectuals eager to promote “national learning,” Ge offers an insightful and erudite account of how China sees its place in the world. As he wrestles with complex historical and cultural forces guiding the inner workings of an often misunderstood nation, Ge also teases out many nuances of China’s encounter with the contemporary world, using China’s past to explain aspects of its present and to provide insight into various paths the nation might follow as the twenty-first century unfolds.
REVIEWS
This erudite polemic targets the aggressive nationalism that is widespread in China today.
-- Andrew J. Nathan Foreign Affairs
This book is remarkable. It helps us see how the Chinese see themselves, addressing issues such as China’s borders, its relations with its neighbors, and the notion that China and the West are on a collision course. Ge is not defending or attacking anything, but wants to talk to us about where China is with respect to the world, by thinking historically, by relativizing where we all find ourselves now. Sabre-rattlers on all sides, beware.
-- Timothy Brook, University of British Columbia
Non-Chinese speakers have far too little access to the opinions of Chinese intellectuals today. This book gives an excellent overview of the main issues that lie behind the conundrum of a modern Chinese identity. Ge’s voice is one that most definitely needs to be heard by everyone in the West who ‘worries about China.’
-- Mark C. Elliott, Harvard University
There is much to be learned from this critically engaged, liberal-minded, historically informed questioning from within China of Chinese national identity… Most importantly, What Is China? provides English-language readers with access to a thoughtful attempt to answer that question by a respected and influential Chinese scholar.
-- Richard Belsky Pacific Affairs
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Cover
Title Page
Copyright
Contents
Preface
Translator’s Introduction
Introduction: On the Historical Formation of “China” and the Dilemma of Chinese Identity
1. Worldviews: From “All-under-Heaven” in Ancient China to the “Myriad States” in the Modern World
2. Borders: On “Chinese” Territory
3. Ethnicity: Including the “Four Barbarians” in “China”?
4. History: Chinese Culture from a Long-Term Perspective
5. Peripheries: How China, Korea, and Japan Have Understood One Another since the Sixteenth and Seventeenth Centuries
6. Practical Questions: Will Cultural Differences between China and the West Lead to Conflict?