Harvard University Press, 1987 Paper: 978-0-674-68606-9 | Cloth: 978-0-674-68605-2 Library of Congress Classification JA79.T57 1987 Dewey Decimal Classification 172
ABOUT THIS BOOK | REVIEWS | TOC
ABOUT THIS BOOK
Are public officials morally justified in threatening violence, engaging in deception, or forcing citizens to act for their own good? Can individual officials be held morally accountable for the wrongs that governments commit? Dennis Thompson addresses these questions by developing a conception of political ethics that respects the demands of both morality and politics. He criticizes conventional conceptions for failing to appreciate the difference democracy makes, and for ascribing responsibility only to isolated leaders or to impersonal organizations. His book seeks to recapture the sense that men and women, acting for us and together with us in a democratic process, make the moral choices that govern our public life.
Thompson surveys ethical conflicts of public officials over a range of political issues, including nuclear deterrence, foreign intervention, undercover investigation, bureaucratic negligence, campaign finance, the privacy of officials, health care, welfare paternalism, drug and safety regulation, and social experimentation. He views these conflicts from the perspectives of many different kinds of public officials—elected and appointed executives at several levels of government, administrators, judges, legislators, governmental advisers, and even doctors, lawyers, social workers, and journalists whose professional roles often thrust them into public life.
In clarifying the ethical problems faced by officials, Thompson combines theoretical analysis with practical prescription, and begins to define a field of inquiry for which many have said there is a need but to which few have yet contributed. Philosophers, political scientists, policy analysts, sociologists, lawyers, and other professionals interested in ethics in government will gain insight from this book.
REVIEWS
Immediately upon publication, this becomes the text of choice for courses on the ethics of public officials… The major theme for which the book will be widely noticed and long remembered [is the] aim ‘to preserve the essentials of the traditional idea of personal responsibility against the pressures of organizational life.’
-- Political Theory
The discussions throughout are careful and measured, conversant with a wide literature, and full of useful distinctions that allow many stalemates and logjams in the public understanding of political ethics to be bypassed or broken through… Even if readers are unconvinced by Thompson’s particular views, they will find in the essays indispensable tools for mounting alternative conclusions.
-- American Political Science Review
This is an important book, not only for its groundbreaking contribution to the study of political ethics, but also more broadly, for its contributions to democratic theory. It should be of use to a wide range of political scientists as well as members of other academic disciplines.
-- Gary L. Jones Perspective
Thompson’s book…sensitively and carefully probe[s] the implications of incorporating notions of ‘personal responsibility’ in our assessment of moral political life.
-- Michigan Law Review
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Contents
Introduction
Problems of the Ethics of Office
Methods of the Ethics of Office
1.
Democratic Dirty Hands
The Persistence of the Problem
The Limits of Democratic Distance
The Assumption of Accountability
Reviewing the Decision
Generalizing the Decision
Mediating the Decision
The End of Dirty Decisions
Democratic Deterrence
2.
The Moral Responsibility of Many Hands
Hierarchical Responsibility
Collective Responsibility
Personal Responsibility
Alternative Causes
Causing and Advising
Good Intentions
The Ignorance of Officials
The Compulsion of Offices
3.
Official Crime and Punishment
The Problem of Moral Responsibility
The Problem of Political Responsibility
Limits of Criminal Responsibility
4.
Legislative Ethics
Minimalist Ethics
Functionalist Ethics
Rationalist Ethics
The Particulars of Generality
The Autonomous Legislator
The Pecuniary Connection
The Necessity of Publicity
5.
The Private Lives of Public Officials
The Value of Privacy
The Scope of Privacy: Substantive Criteria
The Scope of Privacy: Procedural Criteria
6.
Paternalistic Power
The Concept of Paternalism
The Justification of Paternalism
The Paternalism of the Professions
Compulsory Medical Treatment
The Law of Involuntary Guardianship
The Distribution of Public Welfare
The Regulation of Drugs
The Regulation of Safety
7.
The Ethics of Social Experiments
The Story of the Denver Income Maintenance Experiment (DIME)
Harvard University Press, 1987 Paper: 978-0-674-68606-9 Cloth: 978-0-674-68605-2
Are public officials morally justified in threatening violence, engaging in deception, or forcing citizens to act for their own good? Can individual officials be held morally accountable for the wrongs that governments commit? Dennis Thompson addresses these questions by developing a conception of political ethics that respects the demands of both morality and politics. He criticizes conventional conceptions for failing to appreciate the difference democracy makes, and for ascribing responsibility only to isolated leaders or to impersonal organizations. His book seeks to recapture the sense that men and women, acting for us and together with us in a democratic process, make the moral choices that govern our public life.
Thompson surveys ethical conflicts of public officials over a range of political issues, including nuclear deterrence, foreign intervention, undercover investigation, bureaucratic negligence, campaign finance, the privacy of officials, health care, welfare paternalism, drug and safety regulation, and social experimentation. He views these conflicts from the perspectives of many different kinds of public officials—elected and appointed executives at several levels of government, administrators, judges, legislators, governmental advisers, and even doctors, lawyers, social workers, and journalists whose professional roles often thrust them into public life.
In clarifying the ethical problems faced by officials, Thompson combines theoretical analysis with practical prescription, and begins to define a field of inquiry for which many have said there is a need but to which few have yet contributed. Philosophers, political scientists, policy analysts, sociologists, lawyers, and other professionals interested in ethics in government will gain insight from this book.
REVIEWS
Immediately upon publication, this becomes the text of choice for courses on the ethics of public officials… The major theme for which the book will be widely noticed and long remembered [is the] aim ‘to preserve the essentials of the traditional idea of personal responsibility against the pressures of organizational life.’
-- Political Theory
The discussions throughout are careful and measured, conversant with a wide literature, and full of useful distinctions that allow many stalemates and logjams in the public understanding of political ethics to be bypassed or broken through… Even if readers are unconvinced by Thompson’s particular views, they will find in the essays indispensable tools for mounting alternative conclusions.
-- American Political Science Review
This is an important book, not only for its groundbreaking contribution to the study of political ethics, but also more broadly, for its contributions to democratic theory. It should be of use to a wide range of political scientists as well as members of other academic disciplines.
-- Gary L. Jones Perspective
Thompson’s book…sensitively and carefully probe[s] the implications of incorporating notions of ‘personal responsibility’ in our assessment of moral political life.
-- Michigan Law Review
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Contents
Introduction
Problems of the Ethics of Office
Methods of the Ethics of Office
1.
Democratic Dirty Hands
The Persistence of the Problem
The Limits of Democratic Distance
The Assumption of Accountability
Reviewing the Decision
Generalizing the Decision
Mediating the Decision
The End of Dirty Decisions
Democratic Deterrence
2.
The Moral Responsibility of Many Hands
Hierarchical Responsibility
Collective Responsibility
Personal Responsibility
Alternative Causes
Causing and Advising
Good Intentions
The Ignorance of Officials
The Compulsion of Offices
3.
Official Crime and Punishment
The Problem of Moral Responsibility
The Problem of Political Responsibility
Limits of Criminal Responsibility
4.
Legislative Ethics
Minimalist Ethics
Functionalist Ethics
Rationalist Ethics
The Particulars of Generality
The Autonomous Legislator
The Pecuniary Connection
The Necessity of Publicity
5.
The Private Lives of Public Officials
The Value of Privacy
The Scope of Privacy: Substantive Criteria
The Scope of Privacy: Procedural Criteria
6.
Paternalistic Power
The Concept of Paternalism
The Justification of Paternalism
The Paternalism of the Professions
Compulsory Medical Treatment
The Law of Involuntary Guardianship
The Distribution of Public Welfare
The Regulation of Drugs
The Regulation of Safety
7.
The Ethics of Social Experiments
The Story of the Denver Income Maintenance Experiment (DIME)