Deliverance and Submission: Evangelical Women and the Negotiation of Patriarchy in South Korea
by Kelly H. Chong
Harvard University Press, 2008 Cloth: 978-0-674-03107-4 Library of Congress Classification BV1642.K6C46 2008 Dewey Decimal Classification 275.195083082
ABOUT THIS BOOK | TOC
ABOUT THIS BOOK
South Korea is home to one of the most vibrant evangelical Protestant communities in the world. This book investigates the meanings of—and the reasons behind—an intriguing aspect of contemporary South Korean evangelicalism: the intense involvement of middle-class women. Drawing upon extensive ethnographic fieldwork in Seoul that explores the relevance of gender and women’s experiences to Korean evangelicalism, Kelly H. Chong not only helps provide a clearer picture of the evangelical movement’s success in South Korea, but interrogates the global question of contemporary women’s attraction to religious traditionalisms.
In highlighting the growing disjunction between the forces of social transformation that are rapidly liberalizing modern Korean society, and a social system that continues to uphold key patriarchal structures on both societal and familial levels, Chong relates women’s religious involvement to the contradictions of South Korea’s recent socio-cultural changes and complex engagement with modernity. By focusing on the ways in which women’s religious participation constitutes—both spiritually and institutionally—an important part of their effort to negotiate the problems and dilemmas of contemporary family and gender relations, this book explores the contradictory significance of evangelical beliefs and practices for women, which simultaneously opens up possibilities for gender negotiation/resistance, and for women’s redomestication.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Contents
List of Tables xiii
Note to the Reader xiv
Introduction 1
1 Entering the Field: Protestant Evangelicalism in Korea 14
A Brief History 15
The Contemporary Picture: Beliefs, Practices, and Culture 24
Setting and Method 32
A Note on Ethnography 39
2 Women's Conversion and the Contradictions of
Contemporary Gender and Family Relations 48
The Economic "Miracle" and the Quandaries
of Compressed Development 53
The Ideology and Structure of Neo-Confucian Patriarchy 58
Changes and Contradictions in Family
and Gender Relations after World War II 63
Women's Domestic Dilemmas 74
Conclusion 80
3 Search for Release, Search for Healing:
Deliverance through Spiritual Practice 82
In Search of Healing: Pathways to Conversion 84
"Opening-Up" the Self 95
The Power of Surrender 99
Love, Forgiveness, and Empowerment 104
Conclusion 109
4 Negotiating Women's Space:
Community, Autonomy, and Empowerment 110
Women in the Church: From "Helpmate" to "Kitchen Herd" 112
Women's Space, Women's Community 117
In Quest of Recognition: God's Work and Status Rewards 121
Confidence and Fearlessness: Toward Internal Transformation 126
Self-Cultivation and Learning 131
Conclusion 133
5 Bargaining with Patriarchy:
The Politics of Submission and Gender within the Church 135
Domesticating Willful Women:
The Evangelical Ideology of Family and Gender 136
The Paradox of Submission 148
Conclusion 170
6 Women's Redomestication and the Question of Consent 171
The Other Side of Religious Power 171
Explaining Consent 176
Ambivalent Subjectivities and Consciousness 185
Conclusion 188
Women and Evangelicalism in South Korea:
Blessing or Burden? 189
Implications for the Study of Women
and Religious Traditionalism 192
The Politics of Resistance and Consent 194
Of Women, Gender, Modernity, and the Future
of Korean Evangelicalism 196
Reference Matter
Notes 203
Bibliography 239
Index 257
Deliverance and Submission: Evangelical Women and the Negotiation of Patriarchy in South Korea
by Kelly H. Chong
Harvard University Press, 2008 Cloth: 978-0-674-03107-4
South Korea is home to one of the most vibrant evangelical Protestant communities in the world. This book investigates the meanings of—and the reasons behind—an intriguing aspect of contemporary South Korean evangelicalism: the intense involvement of middle-class women. Drawing upon extensive ethnographic fieldwork in Seoul that explores the relevance of gender and women’s experiences to Korean evangelicalism, Kelly H. Chong not only helps provide a clearer picture of the evangelical movement’s success in South Korea, but interrogates the global question of contemporary women’s attraction to religious traditionalisms.
In highlighting the growing disjunction between the forces of social transformation that are rapidly liberalizing modern Korean society, and a social system that continues to uphold key patriarchal structures on both societal and familial levels, Chong relates women’s religious involvement to the contradictions of South Korea’s recent socio-cultural changes and complex engagement with modernity. By focusing on the ways in which women’s religious participation constitutes—both spiritually and institutionally—an important part of their effort to negotiate the problems and dilemmas of contemporary family and gender relations, this book explores the contradictory significance of evangelical beliefs and practices for women, which simultaneously opens up possibilities for gender negotiation/resistance, and for women’s redomestication.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Contents
List of Tables xiii
Note to the Reader xiv
Introduction 1
1 Entering the Field: Protestant Evangelicalism in Korea 14
A Brief History 15
The Contemporary Picture: Beliefs, Practices, and Culture 24
Setting and Method 32
A Note on Ethnography 39
2 Women's Conversion and the Contradictions of
Contemporary Gender and Family Relations 48
The Economic "Miracle" and the Quandaries
of Compressed Development 53
The Ideology and Structure of Neo-Confucian Patriarchy 58
Changes and Contradictions in Family
and Gender Relations after World War II 63
Women's Domestic Dilemmas 74
Conclusion 80
3 Search for Release, Search for Healing:
Deliverance through Spiritual Practice 82
In Search of Healing: Pathways to Conversion 84
"Opening-Up" the Self 95
The Power of Surrender 99
Love, Forgiveness, and Empowerment 104
Conclusion 109
4 Negotiating Women's Space:
Community, Autonomy, and Empowerment 110
Women in the Church: From "Helpmate" to "Kitchen Herd" 112
Women's Space, Women's Community 117
In Quest of Recognition: God's Work and Status Rewards 121
Confidence and Fearlessness: Toward Internal Transformation 126
Self-Cultivation and Learning 131
Conclusion 133
5 Bargaining with Patriarchy:
The Politics of Submission and Gender within the Church 135
Domesticating Willful Women:
The Evangelical Ideology of Family and Gender 136
The Paradox of Submission 148
Conclusion 170
6 Women's Redomestication and the Question of Consent 171
The Other Side of Religious Power 171
Explaining Consent 176
Ambivalent Subjectivities and Consciousness 185
Conclusion 188
Women and Evangelicalism in South Korea:
Blessing or Burden? 189
Implications for the Study of Women
and Religious Traditionalism 192
The Politics of Resistance and Consent 194
Of Women, Gender, Modernity, and the Future
of Korean Evangelicalism 196
Reference Matter
Notes 203
Bibliography 239
Index 257