Between Dreams and Reality: The Military Examination in Late Chosŏn Korea, 1600-1894
by Eugene Y. Park
Harvard University Press, 2007 Cloth: 978-0-674-02502-8 Library of Congress Classification U635.K6P37 2007 Dewey Decimal Classification 355.2234
ABOUT THIS BOOK | TOC
ABOUT THIS BOOK
From the mid-seventeenth to the mid-nineteenth century, millions of Korean men from all walks of life trained in the arts of war to prepare not for actual combat but to sit for the state military examination (mukwa). Despite this widespread interest, only for a small minority did passing the test lead to appointment as a military official. Why, then, did so many men aspire to the mukwa?
Eugene Y. Park argues that the mukwa was not only the state's primary instrument for recruiting aristocrats as new members to the military bureaucracy but also a means by which the ruling elite of Seoul could partially satisfy the status aspirations of marginalized regional elites, secondary status groups, commoners, and manumitted slaves. Unlike the civil examination (munkwa), however, that assured successful examinees posts in the prestigious central bureaucracy, achievement in the mukwa did not enable them to gain political power or membership in the existing aristocracy.
A wealth of empirical data and primary sources drives Park's study: a database of more than 32,000 military examination graduates; a range of new and underutilized documents such as court records, household registers, local gazetteers, private memoirs, examination rosters, and genealogies; and products of popular culture, such as p'ansori storytelling and vernacular fiction. Drawing on this extensive evidence, Park provides a comprehensive sociopolitical history of the mukwa system in late Choson Korea.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Contents
List of Figures, Maps, and Tables xiii
List of Abbreviations xv
Introduction 1
1 The Early Military Examination System 15
Koryo Antecedents and the Founding of Choson 16
A Military to Serve the State 19
The New Military Examination System 25
The Declining Political Stature of Military Examination Graduates 33
Continuing Aristocratic Domination of the Military Examination 38
Summation 47
2 The Rise of a Military Aristocracy 49
The Military Examination System After 1592 50
Late Choson Critiques of the Military Examination System 60
The Emergence of Central Military Official Descent Lines 68
Why Specialization? 73
The Military Aristocracy and Politics 79
Summation 84
3 Local Elites and the Military Examination 86
Southern Local Yangban 88
The Kaesong Elite 100
The Northern Elites of P'yongan and Hamgyong Provinces 105
Summation 114
4 Yangban Cohesiveness and the Choson Dynasty 117
Marriage Ties 119
Adoption 123
Branch Affiliation Diversity 125
The Government Sale of Ranks and Offices 128
The Sacrosanct Aristocracy 132
Summation 141
5 Nonelites and the Military Examination 143
Anecdotal and Legal Evidence of Nonelite Participation
in the Seventeenth-Century 144
The Actual Extent of Nonelite Participation:
The Examination Roster Data 149
Nonelites and Late Choson Social Mobility 154
The Limitations of the Military Examination
as a Ladder of Success 158
Nonelite Aspirations 162
Military Ethos and Popular Culture 168
Summation 177
Conclusion: The State and the Military Examination System 179
Appendixes
A New Local Military Competitions from the Reigns
of Sukchong through Yongjo, 1674-1776 189
B Highest Achievements of Military Examination Passers
from Elite Military Lines, 1592-1894 190
Reference Matter
Notes 195
Works Cited 237
Character List 255
Index 265
Between Dreams and Reality: The Military Examination in Late Chosŏn Korea, 1600-1894
by Eugene Y. Park
Harvard University Press, 2007 Cloth: 978-0-674-02502-8
From the mid-seventeenth to the mid-nineteenth century, millions of Korean men from all walks of life trained in the arts of war to prepare not for actual combat but to sit for the state military examination (mukwa). Despite this widespread interest, only for a small minority did passing the test lead to appointment as a military official. Why, then, did so many men aspire to the mukwa?
Eugene Y. Park argues that the mukwa was not only the state's primary instrument for recruiting aristocrats as new members to the military bureaucracy but also a means by which the ruling elite of Seoul could partially satisfy the status aspirations of marginalized regional elites, secondary status groups, commoners, and manumitted slaves. Unlike the civil examination (munkwa), however, that assured successful examinees posts in the prestigious central bureaucracy, achievement in the mukwa did not enable them to gain political power or membership in the existing aristocracy.
A wealth of empirical data and primary sources drives Park's study: a database of more than 32,000 military examination graduates; a range of new and underutilized documents such as court records, household registers, local gazetteers, private memoirs, examination rosters, and genealogies; and products of popular culture, such as p'ansori storytelling and vernacular fiction. Drawing on this extensive evidence, Park provides a comprehensive sociopolitical history of the mukwa system in late Choson Korea.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Contents
List of Figures, Maps, and Tables xiii
List of Abbreviations xv
Introduction 1
1 The Early Military Examination System 15
Koryo Antecedents and the Founding of Choson 16
A Military to Serve the State 19
The New Military Examination System 25
The Declining Political Stature of Military Examination Graduates 33
Continuing Aristocratic Domination of the Military Examination 38
Summation 47
2 The Rise of a Military Aristocracy 49
The Military Examination System After 1592 50
Late Choson Critiques of the Military Examination System 60
The Emergence of Central Military Official Descent Lines 68
Why Specialization? 73
The Military Aristocracy and Politics 79
Summation 84
3 Local Elites and the Military Examination 86
Southern Local Yangban 88
The Kaesong Elite 100
The Northern Elites of P'yongan and Hamgyong Provinces 105
Summation 114
4 Yangban Cohesiveness and the Choson Dynasty 117
Marriage Ties 119
Adoption 123
Branch Affiliation Diversity 125
The Government Sale of Ranks and Offices 128
The Sacrosanct Aristocracy 132
Summation 141
5 Nonelites and the Military Examination 143
Anecdotal and Legal Evidence of Nonelite Participation
in the Seventeenth-Century 144
The Actual Extent of Nonelite Participation:
The Examination Roster Data 149
Nonelites and Late Choson Social Mobility 154
The Limitations of the Military Examination
as a Ladder of Success 158
Nonelite Aspirations 162
Military Ethos and Popular Culture 168
Summation 177
Conclusion: The State and the Military Examination System 179
Appendixes
A New Local Military Competitions from the Reigns
of Sukchong through Yongjo, 1674-1776 189
B Highest Achievements of Military Examination Passers
from Elite Military Lines, 1592-1894 190
Reference Matter
Notes 195
Works Cited 237
Character List 255
Index 265