Schooling Selves: Autonomy, Interdependence, and Reform in Japanese Junior High Education
by Peter Cave
University of Chicago Press, 2016 Cloth: 978-0-226-36772-9 | Paper: 978-0-226-36786-6 | eISBN: 978-0-226-36805-4 Library of Congress Classification LB1556.7.J3C38 2016 Dewey Decimal Classification 373.52
ABOUT THIS BOOK | AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY | REVIEWS | TOC | REQUEST ACCESSIBLE FILE
ABOUT THIS BOOK
Balancing the development of autonomy with that of social interdependence is a crucial aim of education in any society, but nowhere has it been more hotly debated than in Japan, where controversial education reforms over the past twenty years have attempted to reconcile the two goals. In this book, Peter Cave explores these reforms as they have played out at the junior high level, the most intense pressure point in the Japanese system, a time when students prepare for the high school entrance exams that will largely determine their educational trajectories and future livelihoods.
Cave examines the implementation of “relaxed education” reforms that attempted to promote individual autonomy and free thinking in Japanese classrooms. As he shows, however, these policies were eventually transformed by educators and school administrators into curricula and approaches that actually promoted social integration over individuality, an effect opposite to the reforms’ intended purpose. With vivid detail, he offers the voices of teachers, students, and parents to show what happens when national education policies run up against long-held beliefs and practices, and what their complex and conflicted interactions say about the production of self and community in education. The result is a fascinating analysis of a turbulent era in Japanese education that offers lessons for educational practitioners in any country.
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY
Peter Cave is a lecturer in Japanese studies at the University of Manchester and the author of Primary School in Japan.
REVIEWS
“In this wonderfully detailed ethnography, which draws on over a dozen years of fieldwork—often visiting the same event many years apart—Cave robustly challenges the persistent view of Japanese junior high schools as unchanging institutions that serve primarily to prepare children for a life focused on group rather than individual activity. In doing so, Cave shifts our understanding of some of the key topics not only in Japanese studies but also in anthropology more generally, such as personhood, autonomy, creativity, and how social change both occurs and is resisted.”
— Roger Goodman, author of Children of the Japanese State
“A nuanced look at recent efforts to alter the context for teaching and learning in Japan. Not only does Cave’s analysis deepen our understanding of the education system, it also raises some pithy questions about social change in Japan and the tensions that have surfaced as government leaders attempt to convince citizens to adopt behaviors that often clash with established practices.”
— Christopher Bjork, author of High-Stakes Schooling
“Schooling Selves is an insightful longitudinal ethnographic study of how Japanese junior high schools have interpreted, and struggled to implement, national reform policies to promote individual autonomy. Its outstanding feature is the extensive coverage, exceeding any previous studies, of aspects of daily schooling that Cave devotes to examining this process, including extracurricular clubs, the subjects of Japanese and integrated studies, sports days, choral contests, cultural festivals, and assessment. Readers can unpack the complexity and underlying reasoning for the contradiction-ridden policy implementation process through the author’s thick description of everyday schooling; and in so doing, they gain an insight into how individual autonomy, interdependence, and the social whole are conceived by teachers, parents, and students, and in the wider society.”
— Kaori H. Okano, La Trobe University
“Cave examines the impact of Japanese educational reform policies in junior high schools through a longitudinal, multi-site ethnographic study…. Throughout the book, Cave provides insight into how concepts such as individuality, autonomy, education (guidance), and equity are defined and understood in contemporary Japanese society and how they are enacted in the institution of junior high schools.”
— Schools
"This book will be essential reading for scholars researching contemporary Japanese education and society and more generally for all those seeking a greater understanding of the phenomenon of educational intensity in Japan and across East Asia. As such, it is just the latest in an extensive and impressive body of work that also includes an earlier volume, Primary School in Japan (Routledge, 2009)."
— Comparative Education Review
"Cave’s detailed ethnography, drawing on over a dozen years of fieldwork, makes this book a highly useful contribution to the field of Japanese education. The book offers an insightful evaluation of the educational reform, as Cave reveals how the reform was interpreted and implemented by the teachers in practice. Its outstanding feature is the extensive coverage of different aspects of daily schooling."
— Social Science Japan Journal
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Acknowledgments
Note on Conventions
Introduction
Chapter 1. Individuals, Autonomy, and Society in Japanese Education
Chapter 2. Reshaping Reform: Discipline, Autonomy, and Group Relations
Chapter 3. Classes, Clubs, and Control
Chapter 4. Mass Games and Dreams of Youth
Chapter 5. Changing the Classroom? Autonomy and Expression in Japanese Language and Literature
Chapter 6. The Challenges and Trials of Curricular Change
Chapter 7. To Graduation and Beyond: High School Entrance and Juku
Conclusion
Fieldwork Appendix
Notes
Glossary
References
Index
REQUEST ACCESSIBLE FILE
If you are a student who cannot use this book in printed form, BiblioVault may be able to supply you
with an electronic file for alternative access.
Please have the accessibility coordinator at your school fill out this form.
Schooling Selves: Autonomy, Interdependence, and Reform in Japanese Junior High Education
by Peter Cave
University of Chicago Press, 2016 Cloth: 978-0-226-36772-9 Paper: 978-0-226-36786-6 eISBN: 978-0-226-36805-4
Balancing the development of autonomy with that of social interdependence is a crucial aim of education in any society, but nowhere has it been more hotly debated than in Japan, where controversial education reforms over the past twenty years have attempted to reconcile the two goals. In this book, Peter Cave explores these reforms as they have played out at the junior high level, the most intense pressure point in the Japanese system, a time when students prepare for the high school entrance exams that will largely determine their educational trajectories and future livelihoods.
Cave examines the implementation of “relaxed education” reforms that attempted to promote individual autonomy and free thinking in Japanese classrooms. As he shows, however, these policies were eventually transformed by educators and school administrators into curricula and approaches that actually promoted social integration over individuality, an effect opposite to the reforms’ intended purpose. With vivid detail, he offers the voices of teachers, students, and parents to show what happens when national education policies run up against long-held beliefs and practices, and what their complex and conflicted interactions say about the production of self and community in education. The result is a fascinating analysis of a turbulent era in Japanese education that offers lessons for educational practitioners in any country.
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY
Peter Cave is a lecturer in Japanese studies at the University of Manchester and the author of Primary School in Japan.
REVIEWS
“In this wonderfully detailed ethnography, which draws on over a dozen years of fieldwork—often visiting the same event many years apart—Cave robustly challenges the persistent view of Japanese junior high schools as unchanging institutions that serve primarily to prepare children for a life focused on group rather than individual activity. In doing so, Cave shifts our understanding of some of the key topics not only in Japanese studies but also in anthropology more generally, such as personhood, autonomy, creativity, and how social change both occurs and is resisted.”
— Roger Goodman, author of Children of the Japanese State
“A nuanced look at recent efforts to alter the context for teaching and learning in Japan. Not only does Cave’s analysis deepen our understanding of the education system, it also raises some pithy questions about social change in Japan and the tensions that have surfaced as government leaders attempt to convince citizens to adopt behaviors that often clash with established practices.”
— Christopher Bjork, author of High-Stakes Schooling
“Schooling Selves is an insightful longitudinal ethnographic study of how Japanese junior high schools have interpreted, and struggled to implement, national reform policies to promote individual autonomy. Its outstanding feature is the extensive coverage, exceeding any previous studies, of aspects of daily schooling that Cave devotes to examining this process, including extracurricular clubs, the subjects of Japanese and integrated studies, sports days, choral contests, cultural festivals, and assessment. Readers can unpack the complexity and underlying reasoning for the contradiction-ridden policy implementation process through the author’s thick description of everyday schooling; and in so doing, they gain an insight into how individual autonomy, interdependence, and the social whole are conceived by teachers, parents, and students, and in the wider society.”
— Kaori H. Okano, La Trobe University
“Cave examines the impact of Japanese educational reform policies in junior high schools through a longitudinal, multi-site ethnographic study…. Throughout the book, Cave provides insight into how concepts such as individuality, autonomy, education (guidance), and equity are defined and understood in contemporary Japanese society and how they are enacted in the institution of junior high schools.”
— Schools
"This book will be essential reading for scholars researching contemporary Japanese education and society and more generally for all those seeking a greater understanding of the phenomenon of educational intensity in Japan and across East Asia. As such, it is just the latest in an extensive and impressive body of work that also includes an earlier volume, Primary School in Japan (Routledge, 2009)."
— Comparative Education Review
"Cave’s detailed ethnography, drawing on over a dozen years of fieldwork, makes this book a highly useful contribution to the field of Japanese education. The book offers an insightful evaluation of the educational reform, as Cave reveals how the reform was interpreted and implemented by the teachers in practice. Its outstanding feature is the extensive coverage of different aspects of daily schooling."
— Social Science Japan Journal
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Acknowledgments
Note on Conventions
Introduction
Chapter 1. Individuals, Autonomy, and Society in Japanese Education
Chapter 2. Reshaping Reform: Discipline, Autonomy, and Group Relations
Chapter 3. Classes, Clubs, and Control
Chapter 4. Mass Games and Dreams of Youth
Chapter 5. Changing the Classroom? Autonomy and Expression in Japanese Language and Literature
Chapter 6. The Challenges and Trials of Curricular Change
Chapter 7. To Graduation and Beyond: High School Entrance and Juku
Conclusion
Fieldwork Appendix
Notes
Glossary
References
Index
REQUEST ACCESSIBLE FILE
If you are a student who cannot use this book in printed form, BiblioVault may be able to supply you
with an electronic file for alternative access.
Please have the accessibility coordinator at your school fill out this form.
It can take 2-3 weeks for requests to be filled.
ABOUT THIS BOOK | AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY | REVIEWS | TOC | REQUEST ACCESSIBLE FILE