Making the Mission: Planning and Ethnicity in San Francisco
by Ocean Howell
University of Chicago Press, 2015 eISBN: 978-0-226-29028-7 | Cloth: 978-0-226-14139-8 Library of Congress Classification HT177.S3H69 2015 Dewey Decimal Classification 307.341609794611
ABOUT THIS BOOK | AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY | REVIEWS | TOC | REQUEST ACCESSIBLE FILE
ABOUT THIS BOOK
In the aftermath of the 1906 San Francisco earthquake, residents of the city’s iconic Mission District bucked the city-wide development plan, defiantly announcing that in their neighborhood, they would be calling the shots. Ever since, the Mission has become known as a city within a city, and a place where residents have, over the last century, organized and reorganized themselves to make the neighborhood in their own image.
In Making the Mission, Ocean Howell tells the story of how residents of the Mission District organized to claim the right to plan their own neighborhood and how they mobilized a politics of place and ethnicity to create a strong, often racialized identity—a pattern that would repeat itself again and again throughout the twentieth century. Surveying the perspectives of formal and informal groups, city officials and district residents, local and federal agencies, Howell articulates how these actors worked with and against one another to establish the very ideas of the public and the public interest, as well as to negotiate and renegotiate what the neighborhood wanted. In the process, he shows that national narratives about how cities grow and change are fundamentally insufficient; everything is always shaped by local actors and concerns.
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY
Ocean Howell is assistant professor of history in the Clark Honors College and the Department of the History of Art and Architecture at the University of Oregon.
REVIEWS
“Using the neighborhood-oriented approach that he champions, Howell has been able to approach the issues of local power, planning, class, and race with a contextual sensitivity that is often missing in more macro studies. This allows him to make important nuanced observations that will force readers to rethink how they approach their subsequent teaching and research. Making the Mission will challenge readers’ assumptions about the complex relationships that shape neighborhoods, cities, and metropolitan areas; ethnic and racial relations; urban planning and governmental and citizen involvement in it; and the historical narratives that have come to dominate each of these.”
— Janice L. Reiff, University of California, Los Angeles
“Do cities make neighborhoods or do neighborhoods make cities? In this masterful synthesis of politics, culture and the built environment, Howell makes a powerful case for the role of small-scale social formations in the making of the civic whole. As San Francisco’s Mission District emerges as the latest symbol of gentrification and its discontents, this study should not be missed.”
— Eric Avila, University of California, Los Angeles
“Making the Mission offers a provocative history of neighborhood power and urban planning. This elegantly written and beautifully illustrated book reveals that modern-day fights against gentrification are rooted in neighborhood ideas and institutions stretching back to the early twentieth century. Howell’s sweeping narrative shows that neighborhoods often shaped and even directed the planning policies of city hall and the federal government. The neighborhood was a central ‘actor’ in the development of space and formation of race. Howell’s history leaves us with important lessons about the opportunities and obstacles facing today's campaigns for neighborhood self-governance.”
— Christopher Agee, author of The Streets of San Francisco: Policing and the Creation of a Cosmopolitan Liberal Politics
“San Francisco’s Mission district deserves this sophisticated and fascinating history. Howell offers a rare frame for seeing an entire city through the lens of a single neighborhood. Making the Mission remaps the dynamics of power, planning, center and periphery, for U.S. cities in the twentieth century.”
— Alison Isenberg, author of Downtown America: A History of Place and the People Who Made It
“The Mission’s pre-1960’s history has rarely been chronicled and Howell makes a significant contribution to our understanding of this period. He shows how strongly the Mission identified as a working-class community, seeing itself as almost a separate city from the rest of San Francisco (a spirit that hasn’t changed).”
— BeyondChron
“Howell recounts a rapid transformation of the district that seemed to surround Mission Dolores and then almost swallow it. Highly recommended.”
— Choice
“A deeply researched, beautifully written and illustrated, and timely account of how the people and institutions of the Mission district have influenced the long-term development of the city of San Francisco. Howell has made a major contribution to both American urban history and California urban studies with his highly original addition to the increasingly sophisticated bibliography of San Francisco history. Everyone interested in the City by the Golden Gate from the early twentieth century to the present will want a copy of this book.”
— William Issel, author of San Francisco, 1865-1932: Politics, Power, and Urban Development
“Howell reminds us what can be gained by zooming in on the map. Making the Mission is, in some ways, a classic neighborhood study, documenting change over time in one of San Francisco’s most famous districts. But the book is less a study of the Mission itself and more an examination of its unusual influence over neighborhood (and even citywide) planning. . . . [Howell] succeeds in challenging urban historians to go back to the neighborhood.”
— Pacific Historical Review
"An important study about the nature of neighborhoods"
— Southern California Quarterly
"The book provides an important historical perspective on the exceptional ability of the Mission to meet externally directed development pressures with locally organized resistance. . .Planning historians will draw
valuable insights."
— Planning Perspectives
TABLE OF CONTENTS
ONE / Neighborhood Power in Twentieth-Century San Francisco
PART I: NEIGHBORHOOD POWER IN THE “WHITEMAN’S TERRITORY,” 1906–29
TWO / Make No Big Plans: The City Beautiful Meets Improvement Clubs
THREE / Neighborhood Capitalism: Urban Planning, Municipal Government, and the Mission Promotion Association
FOUR / The Mission and the Spatial Imagination: Discourse, Ethnicity, and Architecture
PART II: THE NEW DEAL IN THE MISSION: REVITALIZING COMMUNITY, ERODING LOCAL POWER
FIVE / A New Population, Not a New Public: Latino Diversity in San Francisco and the Mission District
SIX / Economic Equality, Racial Erasure: The Spatial and Cultural Interventions of Federal Public Works Agencies
SEVEN / “No- Lining” and Neighborhood Erasure: Washington, D.C., and Downtown San Francisco Come to the Mission
PART III: PROGRESS FOR WHOM? TRANSPORTATION PLANNING, URBAN RENEWAL, AND MULTIETHNIC COALITION BUILDING, 1945–60
EIGHT / The Motoring Public and Neighborhood Erasure: The Culture and Practice of Postwar Transportation Planning
NINE / Latino as Worker: The Changing Politics of Race in the City and the Neighborhood
PART IV: RETURN TO THE CITY WITHIN A CITY: MULTIETHNIC COALITIONS AND URBAN RENEWAL, 1961–73
TEN / A “Salvable Neighborhood”: Urban Renewal, Model Cities, and the Rise of a Social Planning Regime
ELEVEN / Who Holds Final Authority? The San Francisco Redevelopment Agency and the Mission Council on Redevelopment
TWELVE / The Return to the City within a City: The Mission Coalition Organization and the Devolution of Planning Power
REQUEST ACCESSIBLE FILE
If you are a student who cannot use this book in printed form, BiblioVault may be able to supply you
with an electronic file for alternative access.
Please have the accessibility coordinator at your school fill out this form.
Making the Mission: Planning and Ethnicity in San Francisco
by Ocean Howell
University of Chicago Press, 2015 eISBN: 978-0-226-29028-7 Cloth: 978-0-226-14139-8
In the aftermath of the 1906 San Francisco earthquake, residents of the city’s iconic Mission District bucked the city-wide development plan, defiantly announcing that in their neighborhood, they would be calling the shots. Ever since, the Mission has become known as a city within a city, and a place where residents have, over the last century, organized and reorganized themselves to make the neighborhood in their own image.
In Making the Mission, Ocean Howell tells the story of how residents of the Mission District organized to claim the right to plan their own neighborhood and how they mobilized a politics of place and ethnicity to create a strong, often racialized identity—a pattern that would repeat itself again and again throughout the twentieth century. Surveying the perspectives of formal and informal groups, city officials and district residents, local and federal agencies, Howell articulates how these actors worked with and against one another to establish the very ideas of the public and the public interest, as well as to negotiate and renegotiate what the neighborhood wanted. In the process, he shows that national narratives about how cities grow and change are fundamentally insufficient; everything is always shaped by local actors and concerns.
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY
Ocean Howell is assistant professor of history in the Clark Honors College and the Department of the History of Art and Architecture at the University of Oregon.
REVIEWS
“Using the neighborhood-oriented approach that he champions, Howell has been able to approach the issues of local power, planning, class, and race with a contextual sensitivity that is often missing in more macro studies. This allows him to make important nuanced observations that will force readers to rethink how they approach their subsequent teaching and research. Making the Mission will challenge readers’ assumptions about the complex relationships that shape neighborhoods, cities, and metropolitan areas; ethnic and racial relations; urban planning and governmental and citizen involvement in it; and the historical narratives that have come to dominate each of these.”
— Janice L. Reiff, University of California, Los Angeles
“Do cities make neighborhoods or do neighborhoods make cities? In this masterful synthesis of politics, culture and the built environment, Howell makes a powerful case for the role of small-scale social formations in the making of the civic whole. As San Francisco’s Mission District emerges as the latest symbol of gentrification and its discontents, this study should not be missed.”
— Eric Avila, University of California, Los Angeles
“Making the Mission offers a provocative history of neighborhood power and urban planning. This elegantly written and beautifully illustrated book reveals that modern-day fights against gentrification are rooted in neighborhood ideas and institutions stretching back to the early twentieth century. Howell’s sweeping narrative shows that neighborhoods often shaped and even directed the planning policies of city hall and the federal government. The neighborhood was a central ‘actor’ in the development of space and formation of race. Howell’s history leaves us with important lessons about the opportunities and obstacles facing today's campaigns for neighborhood self-governance.”
— Christopher Agee, author of The Streets of San Francisco: Policing and the Creation of a Cosmopolitan Liberal Politics
“San Francisco’s Mission district deserves this sophisticated and fascinating history. Howell offers a rare frame for seeing an entire city through the lens of a single neighborhood. Making the Mission remaps the dynamics of power, planning, center and periphery, for U.S. cities in the twentieth century.”
— Alison Isenberg, author of Downtown America: A History of Place and the People Who Made It
“The Mission’s pre-1960’s history has rarely been chronicled and Howell makes a significant contribution to our understanding of this period. He shows how strongly the Mission identified as a working-class community, seeing itself as almost a separate city from the rest of San Francisco (a spirit that hasn’t changed).”
— BeyondChron
“Howell recounts a rapid transformation of the district that seemed to surround Mission Dolores and then almost swallow it. Highly recommended.”
— Choice
“A deeply researched, beautifully written and illustrated, and timely account of how the people and institutions of the Mission district have influenced the long-term development of the city of San Francisco. Howell has made a major contribution to both American urban history and California urban studies with his highly original addition to the increasingly sophisticated bibliography of San Francisco history. Everyone interested in the City by the Golden Gate from the early twentieth century to the present will want a copy of this book.”
— William Issel, author of San Francisco, 1865-1932: Politics, Power, and Urban Development
“Howell reminds us what can be gained by zooming in on the map. Making the Mission is, in some ways, a classic neighborhood study, documenting change over time in one of San Francisco’s most famous districts. But the book is less a study of the Mission itself and more an examination of its unusual influence over neighborhood (and even citywide) planning. . . . [Howell] succeeds in challenging urban historians to go back to the neighborhood.”
— Pacific Historical Review
"An important study about the nature of neighborhoods"
— Southern California Quarterly
"The book provides an important historical perspective on the exceptional ability of the Mission to meet externally directed development pressures with locally organized resistance. . .Planning historians will draw
valuable insights."
— Planning Perspectives
TABLE OF CONTENTS
ONE / Neighborhood Power in Twentieth-Century San Francisco
PART I: NEIGHBORHOOD POWER IN THE “WHITEMAN’S TERRITORY,” 1906–29
TWO / Make No Big Plans: The City Beautiful Meets Improvement Clubs
THREE / Neighborhood Capitalism: Urban Planning, Municipal Government, and the Mission Promotion Association
FOUR / The Mission and the Spatial Imagination: Discourse, Ethnicity, and Architecture
PART II: THE NEW DEAL IN THE MISSION: REVITALIZING COMMUNITY, ERODING LOCAL POWER
FIVE / A New Population, Not a New Public: Latino Diversity in San Francisco and the Mission District
SIX / Economic Equality, Racial Erasure: The Spatial and Cultural Interventions of Federal Public Works Agencies
SEVEN / “No- Lining” and Neighborhood Erasure: Washington, D.C., and Downtown San Francisco Come to the Mission
PART III: PROGRESS FOR WHOM? TRANSPORTATION PLANNING, URBAN RENEWAL, AND MULTIETHNIC COALITION BUILDING, 1945–60
EIGHT / The Motoring Public and Neighborhood Erasure: The Culture and Practice of Postwar Transportation Planning
NINE / Latino as Worker: The Changing Politics of Race in the City and the Neighborhood
PART IV: RETURN TO THE CITY WITHIN A CITY: MULTIETHNIC COALITIONS AND URBAN RENEWAL, 1961–73
TEN / A “Salvable Neighborhood”: Urban Renewal, Model Cities, and the Rise of a Social Planning Regime
ELEVEN / Who Holds Final Authority? The San Francisco Redevelopment Agency and the Mission Council on Redevelopment
TWELVE / The Return to the City within a City: The Mission Coalition Organization and the Devolution of Planning Power
REQUEST ACCESSIBLE FILE
If you are a student who cannot use this book in printed form, BiblioVault may be able to supply you
with an electronic file for alternative access.
Please have the accessibility coordinator at your school fill out this form.
It can take 2-3 weeks for requests to be filled.
ABOUT THIS BOOK | AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY | REVIEWS | TOC | REQUEST ACCESSIBLE FILE